Percolation threshold

From testwiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Template:Short description Template:Network science Template:Use American English Template:Use mdy dates Template:Technical

The percolation threshold is a mathematical concept in percolation theory that describes the formation of long-range connectivity in random systems. Below the threshold a giant connected component does not exist; while above it, there exists a giant component of the order of system size. In engineering and coffee making, percolation represents the flow of fluids through porous media, but in the mathematics and physics worlds it generally refers to simplified lattice models of random systems or networks (graphs), and the nature of the connectivity in them. The percolation threshold is the critical value of the occupation probability p, or more generally a critical surface for a group of parameters p1, p2, ..., such that infinite connectivity (percolation) first occurs.[1]

Percolation models

The most common percolation model is to take a regular lattice, like a square lattice, and make it into a random network by randomly "occupying" sites (vertices) or bonds (edges) with a statistically independent probability p. At a critical threshold pc, large clusters and long-range connectivity first appear, and this is called the percolation threshold. Depending on the method for obtaining the random network, one distinguishes between the site percolation threshold and the bond percolation threshold. More general systems have several probabilities p1, p2, etc., and the transition is characterized by a critical surface or manifold. One can also consider continuum systems, such as overlapping disks and spheres placed randomly, or the negative space (Swiss-cheese models).

To understand the threshold, you can consider a quantity such as the probability that there is a continuous path from one boundary to another along occupied sites or bonds—that is, within a single cluster. For example, one can consider a square system, and ask for the probability P that there is a path from the top boundary to the bottom boundary. As a function of the occupation probability p, one finds a sigmoidal plot that goes from P=0 at p=0 to P=1 at p=1. The larger the square is compared to the lattice spacing, the sharper the transition will be. When the system size goes to infinity, P(p) will be a step function at the threshold value pc. For finite large systems, P(pc) is a constant whose value depends upon the shape of the system; for the square system discussed above, P(pc)=Template:Frac exactly for any lattice by a simple symmetry argument.

There are other signatures of the critical threshold. For example, the size distribution (number of clusters of size s) drops off as a power-law for large s at the threshold, ns(pc) ~ s−τ, where τ is a dimension-dependent percolation critical exponents. For an infinite system, the critical threshold corresponds to the first point (as p increases) where the size of the clusters become infinite.

In the systems described so far, it has been assumed that the occupation of a site or bond is completely random—this is the so-called Bernoulli percolation. For a continuum system, random occupancy corresponds to the points being placed by a Poisson process. Further variations involve correlated percolation, such as percolation clusters related to Ising and Potts models of ferromagnets, in which the bonds are put down by the Fortuin–Kasteleyn method.[2] In bootstrap or k-sat percolation, sites and/or bonds are first occupied and then successively culled from a system if a site does not have at least k neighbors. Another important model of percolation, in a different universality class altogether, is directed percolation, where connectivity along a bond depends upon the direction of the flow. Another variation of recent interest is Explosive Percolation, whose thresholds are listed on that page.

Over the last several decades, a tremendous amount of work has gone into finding exact and approximate values of the percolation thresholds for a variety of these systems. Exact thresholds are only known for certain two-dimensional lattices that can be broken up into a self-dual array, such that under a triangle-triangle transformation, the system remains the same. Studies using numerical methods have led to numerous improvements in algorithms and several theoretical discoveries.

Simple duality in two dimensions implies that all fully triangulated lattices (e.g., the triangular, union jack, cross dual, martini dual and asanoha or 3-12 dual, and the Delaunay triangulation) all have site thresholds of Template:Frac, and self-dual lattices (square, martini-B) have bond thresholds of Template:Frac.

The notation such as (4,82) comes from Grünbaum and Shephard,[3] and indicates that around a given vertex, going in the clockwise direction, one encounters first a square and then two octagons. Besides the eleven Archimedean lattices composed of regular polygons with every site equivalent, many other more complicated lattices with sites of different classes have been studied.

Error bars in the last digit or digits are shown by numbers in parentheses. Thus, 0.729724(3) signifies 0.729724 ± 0.000003, and 0.74042195(80) signifies 0.74042195 ± 0.00000080. The error bars variously represent one or two standard deviations in net error (including statistical and expected systematic error), or an empirical confidence interval, depending upon the source.

Percolation on networks

For a random tree-like network (i.e., a connected network with no cycle) without degree-degree correlation, it can be shown that such network can have a giant component, and the percolation threshold (transmission probability) is given by

pc=1g1(1)=kk2k.

Where g1(z) is the generating function corresponding to the excess degree distribution, k is the average degree of the network and k2 is the second moment of the degree distribution. So, for example, for an ER network, since the degree distribution is a Poisson distribution, wherek2=k2+k, the threshold is at pc=k1.

In networks with low clustering, 0<C1, the critical point gets scaled by (1C)1 such that:[4]

pc=11C1g1(1).

This indicates that for a given degree distribution, the clustering leads to a larger percolation threshold, mainly because for a fixed number of links, the clustering structure reinforces the core of the network with the price of diluting the global connections. For networks with high clustering, strong clustering could induce the core–periphery structure, in which the core and periphery might percolate at different critical points, and the above approximate treatment is not applicable.[5]

Percolation in 2D

Thresholds on Archimedean lattices

This is a picture[6] of the 11 Archimedean Lattices or Uniform tilings, in which all polygons are regular and each vertex is surrounded by the same sequence of polygons. The notation "(34, 6)", for example, means that every vertex is surrounded by four triangles and one hexagon. Some common names that have been given to these lattices are listed in the table below.

Template:Clear

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
3-12 or super-kagome, (3, 122 ) 3 3 0.807900764... = (1 − 2 sin (Template:Pi/18))Template:Frac[7] 0.74042195(80),[8] 0.74042077(2),[9] 0.740420800(2),[10] 0.7404207988509(8),[11][12] 0.740420798850811610(2),[13]
cross, truncated trihexagonal (4, 6, 12) 3 3 0.746,[14] 0.750,[15] 0.747806(4),[7] 0.7478008(2)[11] 0.6937314(1),[11] 0.69373383(72),[8] 0.693733124922(2)[13]
square octagon, bathroom tile, 4-8, truncated square

(4, 82)

3 - 0.729,[14] 0.729724(3),[7] 0.7297232(5)[11] 0.6768,[16] 0.67680232(63),[8] 0.6768031269(6),[11] 0.6768031243900113(3),[13]
honeycomb (63) 3 3 0.6962(6),[17] 0.697040230(5),[11] 0.6970402(1),[18] 0.6970413(10),[19] 0.697043(3),[7] 0.652703645... = 1-2 sin (π/18), 1+ p3-3p2=0[20]
kagome (3, 6, 3, 6) 4 4 0.652703645... = 1 − 2 sin(Template:Pi/18)[20] 0.5244053(3),[21] 0.52440516(10),[19] 0.52440499(2),[18] 0.524404978(5),[9] 0.52440572...,[22] 0.52440500(1),[10] 0.524404999173(3),[11][12] 0.524404999167439(4)[23] 0.52440499916744820(1)[13]
ruby,[24] rhombitrihexagonal (3, 4, 6, 4) 4 4 0.620,[14] 0.621819(3),[7] 0.62181207(7)[11] 0.52483258(53),[8] 0.5248311(1),[11] 0.524831461573(1)[13]
square (44) 4 4 0.59274(10),[25] 0.59274605079210(2),[23] 0.59274601(2),[11] 0.59274605095(15),[26] 0.59274621(13),[27] 0.592746050786(3),[28] 0.59274621(33),[29] 0.59274598(4),[30][31] 0.59274605(3),[18] 0.593(1),[32] 0.591(1),[33] 0.569(13),[34] 0.59274(5)[35] Template:Frac
snub hexagonal, maple leaf[36] (34,6) 5 5 0.579[15] 0.579498(3)[7] 0.43430621(50),[8] 0.43432764(3),[11] 0.4343283172240(6),[13]
snub square, puzzle (32, 4, 3, 4 ) 5 5 0.550,[14][37] 0.550806(3)[7] 0.41413743(46),[8] 0.4141378476(7),[11] 0.4141378565917(1),[13]
frieze, elongated triangular(33, 42) 5 5 0.549,[14] 0.550213(3),[7] 0.5502(8)[38] 0.4196(6),[38] 0.41964191(43),[8] 0.41964044(1),[11] 0.41964035886369(2) [13]
triangular (36) 6 6 Template:Frac 0.347296355... = 2 sin (Template:Pi/18), 1 + p3 − 3p = 0[20]

Note: sometimes "hexagonal" is used in place of honeycomb, although in some contexts a triangular lattice is also called a hexagonal lattice. z = bulk coordination number.

2D lattices with extended and complex neighborhoods

In this section, sq-1,2,3 corresponds to square (NN+2NN+3NN),[39] etc. Equivalent to square-2N+3N+4N,[40] sq(1,2,3).[41] tri = triangular, hc = honeycomb.

Lattice z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
sq-1, sq-2, sq-3, sq-5 4 0.5927...[39][40] (square site)
sq-1,2, sq-2,3, sq-3,5 8 0.407...[39][40][42] (square matching) 0.25036834(6),[18] 0.2503685,[43] 0.25036840(4)[44]
sq-1,3 8 0.337[39][40] 0.2214995[43]
sq-2,5: 2NN+5NN 8 0.337[40]
hc-1,2,3: honeycomb-NN+2NN+3NN 12 0.300,[41] 0.300,[15] 0.302960... = 1-pc(site, hc) [45]
tri-1,2: triangular-NN+2NN 12 0.295,[41] 0.289,[15] 0.290258(19)[46]
tri-2,3: triangular-2NN+3NN 12 0.232020(36),[47] 0.232020(20)[46]
sq-4: square-4NN 8 0.270...[40]
sq-1,5: square-NN+5NN (r ≤ 2) 8 0.277[40]
sq-1,2,3: square-NN+2NN+3NN 12 0.292,[48] 0.290(5) [49] 0.289,[15] 0.288,[39][40] 0.1522203[43]
sq-2,3,5: square-2NN+3NN+5NN 12 0.288[40]
sq-1,4: square-NN+4NN 12 0.236[40]
sq-2,4: square-2NN+4NN 12 0.225[40]
tri-4: triangular-4NN 12 0.192450(36),[47] 0.1924428(50)[46]
hc-2,4: honeycomb-2NN+4NN 12 0.2374[50]
tri-1,3: triangular-NN+3NN 12 0.264539(21)[46]
tri-1,2,3: triangular-NN+2NN+3NN 18 0.225,[48] 0.215,[15] 0.215459(36)[47] 0.2154657(17)[46]
sq-3,4: 3NN+4NN 12 0.221[40]
sq-1,2,5: NN+2NN+5NN 12 0.240[40] 0.13805374[43]
sq-1,3,5: NN+3NN+5NN 12 0.233[40]
sq-4,5: 4NN+5NN 12 0.199[40]
sq-1,2,4: NN+2NN+4NN 16 0.219[40]
sq-1,3,4: NN+3NN+4NN 16 0.208[40]
sq-2,3,4: 2NN+3NN+4NN 16 0.202[40]
sq-1,4,5: NN+4NN+5NN 16 0.187[40]
sq-2,4,5: 2NN+4NN+5NN 16 0.182[40]
sq-3,4,5: 3NN+4NN+5NN 16 0.179[40]
sq-1,2,3,5 asterisk pattern 16 0.208[40] 0.1032177[43]
tri-4,5: 4NN+5NN 18 0.140250(36),[47]
sq-1,2,3,4: NN+2NN+3NN+4NN (r5) 20 0.19671(9),[51] 0.196,[40] 0.196724(10)[52] 0.0841509[43]
sq-1,2,4,5: NN+2NN+4NN+5NN 20 0.177[40]
sq-1,3,4,5: NN+3NN+4NN+5NN 20 0.172[40]
sq-2,3,4,5: 2NN+3NN+4NN+5NN 20 0.167[40]
sq-1,2,3,5,6 asterisk pattern 20 0.0783110[43]
sq-1,2,3,4,5: NN+2NN+3NN+4NN+5NN (r8) 24 0.164[40]
tri-1,4,5: NN+4NN+5NN 24 0.131660(36)[47]
sq-1,...,6: NN+...+6NN (r≤3) 28 0.142[15] 0.0558493[43]
tri-2,3,4,5: 2NN+3NN+4NN+5NN 30 0.117460(36)[47] 0.135823(27)[46]
tri-1,2,3,4,5: NN+2NN+3NN+4NN+5NN
36 0.115,[15] 0.115740(36),[47] 0.1157399(58) [46]
sq-1,...,7: NN+...+7NN (r10) 36 0.113[15] 0.04169608[43]
sq lat, diamond boundary: dist. ≤ 4 40 0.105(5)[49]
sq-(1,...,8: NN+..+8NN (r13) 44 0.095,[37] 0.095765(5),[52] 0.09580(2)[51]
sq-1,...,9: NN+..+9NN (r≤4) 48 0.086[15] 0.02974268[43]
sq-1,...,11: NN+...+11NN (r18) 60 0.02301190(3)[43]
sq-1,...,23 (r ≤ 7) 148 0.008342595[44]
sq-1,...,32: NN+...+32NN (r72) 224 0.0053050415(33)[43]
sq-1,...,86: NN+...+86NN (r≤15) 708 0.001557644(4)[53]
sq-1,...,141: NN+...+141NN (r389) 1224 0.000880188(90)[43]
sq-1,...,185: NN+...+185NN (r≤23) 1652 0.000645458(4)[53]
sq-1,...,317: NN+...+317NN (r≤31) 3000 0.000349601(3)[53]
sq-1,...,413: NN+...+413NN (r1280) 4016 0.0002594722(11)[43]
sq lat, diamond boundary: dist. ≤ 6 84 0.049(5)[49]
sq lat, diamond boundary: dist. ≤ 8 144 0.028(5)[49]
sq lat, diamond boundary: dist. ≤ 10 220 0.019(5)[49]
2x2 lattice squares* (same as sq-1,2,3,4) 20 φc = 0.58365(2),[52] pc = 0.196724(10),[52] 0.19671(9),[51]
3x3 lattice squares* (same as sq-1,...,8)) 44 φc = 0.59586(2),[52] pc = 0.095765(5),[52] 0.09580(2) [51]
4x4 lattice squares* 76 φc = 0.60648(1),[52] pc = 0.0566227(15),[52] 0.05665(3),[51]
5x5 lattice squares* 116 φc = 0.61467(2),[52] pc = 0.037428(2),[52] 0.03745(2),[51]
6x6 lattice squares* 220 pc = 0.02663(1),[51]
10x10 lattice squares* 436 φc = 0.36391(2),[52] pc = 0.0100576(5) [52]
within 11 x 11 square (r=5) 120 0.01048079(6)[53]
within 15 x 15 square (r=7) 224 0.005287692(22)[53]
within 31 x 31 square (r=15) 960 0.001131082(5) [53]

Here NN = nearest neighbor, 2NN = second nearest neighbor (or next nearest neighbor), 3NN = third nearest neighbor (or next-next nearest neighbor), etc. These are also called 2N, 3N, 4N respectively in some papers.[39]

  • For overlapping or touching squares, pc(site) given here is the net fraction of sites occupied ϕc similar to the ϕc in continuum percolation. The case of a 2×2 square is equivalent to percolation of a square lattice NN+2NN+3NN+4NN or sq-1,2,3,4 with threshold 1(1ϕc)1/4=0.196724(10) with ϕc=0.58365(2).[52] The 3×3 square corresponds to sq-1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8 with z=44 and pc=1(1ϕc)1/9=0.095765(5). The value of z for a k x k square is (2k+1)2-5. For larger overlapping squares, see.[52]

2D distorted lattices

Here, one distorts a regular lattice of unit spacing by moving vertices uniformly within the box (xα,x+α),(yα,y+α), and considers percolation when sites are within Euclidean distance d of each other.

Lattice z α d Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
square 0.2 1.1 0.8025(2)[54]
0.2 1.2 0.6667(5)[54]
0.1 1.1 0.6619(1)[54]

Overlapping shapes on 2D lattices

Site threshold is number of overlapping objects per lattice site. k is the length (net area). Overlapping squares are shown in the complex neighborhood section. Here z is the coordination number to k-mers of either orientation, with z=k2+10k2 for 1×k sticks.

System k z Site coverage φc Site percolation threshold pc
1 x 2 dimer, square lattice 2 22 0.54691[51]

0.5483(2)[55]

0.17956(3)[51]

0.18019(9)[55]

1 x 2 aligned dimer, square lattice 2 14 0.5715(18)[55] 0.3454(13) [55]
1 x 3 trimer, square lattice 3 37 0.49898[51]

0.50004(64)[55]

0.10880(2)[51]

0.1093(2)[55]

1 x 4 stick, square lattice 4 54 0.45761[51] 0.07362(2)[51]
1 x 5 stick, square lattice 5 73 0.42241[51] 0.05341(1)[51]
1 x 6 stick, square lattice 6 94 0.39219[51] 0.04063(2)[51]

The coverage is calculated from pc by ϕc=1(1pc)2k for 1×k sticks, because there are 2k sites where a stick will cause an overlap with a given site.

For aligned 1×k sticks: ϕc=1(1pc)k

Approximate formulas for thresholds of Archimedean lattices

Lattice z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
(3, 122 ) 3
(4, 6, 12) 3
(4, 82) 3 0.676835..., 4p3 + 3p4 − 6 p5 − 2 p6 = 1[56]
honeycomb (63) 3
kagome (3, 6, 3, 6) 4 0.524430..., 3p2 + 6p3 − 12 p4+ 6 p5p6 = 1[57]
(3, 4, 6, 4) 4
square (44) 4 Template:Frac (exact)
(34,6 ) 5 0.434371..., 12p3 + 36p4 − 21p5 − 327 p6 + 69p7 + 2532p8 − 6533 p9 + 8256 p10 − 6255p11 + 2951p12 − 837 p13 + 126 p14 − 7p15 = 1 Template:Citation needed
snub square, puzzle (32, 4, 3, 4 ) 5
(33, 42) 5
triangular (36) 6 Template:Frac (exact)

AB percolation and colored percolation in 2D

In AB percolation, a psite is the proportion of A sites among B sites, and bonds are drawn between sites of opposite species.[58] It is also called antipercolation.

In colored percolation, occupied sites are assigned one of n colors with equal probability, and connection is made along bonds between neighbors of different colors.[59]

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold
triangular AB 6 6 0.2145,[58] 0.21524(34),[60] 0.21564(3)[61]
AB on square-covering lattice 6 6 11pc(site,sq)=0.361835[62]
square three-color 4 4 0.80745(5)[59]
square four-color 4 4 0.73415(4)[59]
square five-color 4 4 0.69864(7)[59]
square six-color 4 4 0.67751(5)[59]
triangular two-color 6 6 0.72890(4)[59]
triangular three-color 6 6 0.63005(4)[59]
triangular four-color 6 6 0.59092(3)[59]
triangular five-color 6 6 0.56991(5)[59]
triangular six-color 6 6 0.55679(5)[59]

Site-bond percolation in 2D

Site bond percolation. Here ps is the site occupation probability and pb is the bond occupation probability, and connectivity is made only if both the sites and bonds along a path are occupied. The criticality condition becomes a curve f(ps,pb) = 0, and some specific critical pairs (ps,pb) are listed below.

Square lattice:

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
square 4 4 0.615185(15)[63] 0.95
0.667280(15)[63] 0.85
0.732100(15)[63] 0.75
0.75 0.726195(15)[63]
0.815560(15)[63] 0.65
0.85 0.615810(30)[63]
0.95 0.533620(15)[63]

Honeycomb (hexagonal) lattice:

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
honeycomb 3 3 0.7275(5)[64] 0.95
0. 0.7610(5)[64] 0.90
0.7986(5)[64] 0.85
0.80 0.8481(5)[64]
0.8401(5)[64] 0.80
0.85 0.7890(5)[64]
0.90 0.7377(5)[64]
0.95 0.6926(5)[64]

Kagome lattice:

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
kagome 4 4 0.6711(4),[64] 0.67097(3)[65] 0.95
0.6914(5),[64] 0.69210(2)[65] 0.90
0.7162(5),[64] 0.71626(3)[65] 0.85
0.7428(5),[64] 0.74339(3)[65] 0.80
0.75 0.7894(9)[64]
0.7757(8),[64] 0.77556(3)[65] 0.75
0.80 0.7152(7)[64]
0.81206(3)[65] 0.70
0.85 0.6556(6)[64]
0.85519(3)[65] 0.65
0.90 0.6046(5)[64]
0.90546(3)[65] 0.60
0.95 0.5615(4)[64]
0.96604(4)[65] 0.55
0.9854(3)[65] 0.53

* For values on different lattices, see "An investigation of site-bond percolation on many lattices".[64]

Approximate formula for site-bond percolation on a honeycomb lattice

Lattice z z Threshold Notes
(63) honeycomb 3 3 pbps[1(pbc/(3pbc))(pbpbc)]=pbc, When equal: ps = pb = 0.82199 approximate formula, ps = site prob., pb = bond prob., pbc = 1 − 2 sin (Template:Pi/18),[19] exact at ps=1, pb=pbc.

Archimedean duals (Laves lattices)

Example image caption
Example image caption

Laves lattices are the duals to the Archimedean lattices. Drawings from.[6] See also Uniform tilings.

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
Cairo pentagonal

D(32,4,3,4)=(Template:Frac)(53)+(Template:Frac)(54)

3,4 3 Template:Frac 0.6501834(2),[11] 0.650184(5)[6] 0.585863... = 1 − pcbond(32,4,3,4)
Pentagonal D(33,42)=(Template:Frac)(54)+(Template:Frac)(53) 3,4 3 Template:Frac 0.6470471(2),[11] 0.647084(5),[6] 0.6471(6)[38] 0.580358... = 1 − pcbond(33,42), 0.5800(6)[38]
D(34,6)=(Template:Frac)(46)+(Template:Frac)(43) 3,6 3 Template:Frac 0.639447[6] 0.565694... = 1 − pcbond(34,6 )
dice, rhombille tiling

D(3,6,3,6) = (Template:Frac)(46) + (Template:Frac)(43)

3,6 4 0.5851(4),[66] 0.585040(5)[6] 0.475595... = 1 − pcbond(3,6,3,6 )
ruby dual

D(3,4,6,4) = (Template:Frac)(46) + (Template:Frac)(43) + (Template:Frac)(44)

3,4,6 4 0.582410(5)[6] 0.475167... = 1 − pcbond(3,4,6,4 )
union jack, tetrakis square tiling

D(4,82) = (Template:Frac)(34) + (Template:Frac)(38)

4,8 6 Template:Frac 0.323197... = 1 − pcbond(4,82 )
bisected hexagon,[67] cross dual

D(4,6,12)= (Template:Frac)(312)+(Template:Frac)(36)+(Template:Frac)(34)

4,6,12 6 Template:Frac 0.306266... = 1 − pcbond(4,6,12)
asanoha (hemp leaf)[68]

D(3, 122)=(Template:Frac)(33)+(Template:Frac)(312)

3,12 6 Template:Frac 0.259579... = 1 − pcbond(3, 122)

2-uniform lattices

Top 3 lattices: #13 #12 #36
Bottom 3 lattices: #34 #37 #11 Template:Clear

20 2 uniform lattices
20 2 uniform lattices

[3] Template:Clear Top 2 lattices: #35 #30
Bottom 2 lattices: #41 #42 Template:Clear

20 2 uniform lattices
20 2 uniform lattices

[3] Template:Clear Top 4 lattices: #22 #23 #21 #20
Bottom 3 lattices: #16 #17 #15

20 2 uniform lattices
20 2 uniform lattices

[3] Template:Clear Top 2 lattices: #31 #32
Bottom lattice: #33

20 2 uniform lattices
20 2 uniform lattices

[3] Template:Clear

# Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
41 (Template:Frac)(3,4,3,12) + (Template:Frac)(3, 122) 4,3 3.5 0.7680(2)[69] 0.67493252(36)Template:Citation needed
42 (Template:Frac)(3,4,6,4) + (Template:Frac)(4,6,12) 4,3 3Template:Frac 0.7157(2)[69] 0.64536587(40)Template:Citation needed
36 (Template:Frac)(36) + (Template:Frac)(32,4,12) 6,4 4 Template:Frac 0.6808(2)[69] 0.55778329(40)Template:Citation needed
15 (Template:Frac)(32,62) + (Template:Frac)(3,6,3,6) 4,4 4 0.6499(2)[69] 0.53632487(40)Template:Citation needed
34 (Template:Frac)(36) + (Template:Frac)(32,62) 6,4 4 Template:Frac 0.6329(2)[69] 0.51707873(70)Template:Citation needed
16 (Template:Frac)(3,42,6) + (Template:Frac)(3,6,3,6) 4,4 4 0.6286(2)[69] 0.51891529(35)Template:Citation needed
17 (Template:Frac)(3,42,6) + (Template:Frac)(3,6,3,6)* 4,4 4 0.6279(2)[69] 0.51769462(35)Template:Citation needed
35 (Template:Frac)(3,42,6) + (Template:Frac)(3,4,6,4) 4,4 4 0.6221(2)[69] 0.51973831(40)Template:Citation needed
11 (Template:Frac)(34,6) + (Template:Frac)(32,62) 5,4 4.5 0.6171(2)[69] 0.48921280(37)Template:Citation needed
37 (Template:Frac)(33,42) + (Template:Frac)(3,4,6,4) 5,4 4.5 0.5885(2)[69] 0.47229486(38)Template:Citation needed
30 (Template:Frac)(32,4,3,4) + (Template:Frac)(3,4,6,4) 5,4 4.5 0.5883(2)[69] 0.46573078(72)Template:Citation needed
23 (Template:Frac)(33,42) + (Template:Frac)(44) 5,4 4.5 0.5720(2)[69] 0.45844622(40)Template:Citation needed
22 (Template:Frac)(33,42) + (Template:Frac)(44) 5,4 4 Template:Frac 0.5648(2)[69] 0.44528611(40)Template:Citation needed
12 (Template:Frac)(36) + (Template:Frac)(34,6) 6,5 5 Template:Frac 0.5607(2)[69] 0.41109890(37)Template:Citation needed
33 (Template:Frac)(33,42) + (Template:Frac)(32,4,3,4) 5,5 5 0.5505(2)[69] 0.41628021(35)Template:Citation needed
32 (Template:Frac)(33,42) + (Template:Frac)(32,4,3,4) 5,5 5 0.5504(2)[69] 0.41549285(36)Template:Citation needed
31 (Template:Frac)(36) + (Template:Frac)(32,4,3,4) 6,5 5 Template:Frac 0.5440(2)[69] 0.40379585(40)Template:Citation needed
13 (Template:Frac)(36) + (Template:Frac)(34,6) 6,5 5.5 0.5407(2)[69] 0.38914898(35)Template:Citation needed
21 (Template:Frac)(36) + (Template:Frac)(33,42) 6,5 5 Template:Frac 0.5342(2)[69] 0.39491996(40)Template:Citation needed
20 (Template:Frac)(36) + (Template:Frac)(33,42) 6,5 5.5 0.5258(2)[69] 0.38285085(38)Template:Citation needed

Inhomogeneous 2-uniform lattice

2-uniform lattice #37

This figure shows something similar to the 2-uniform lattice #37, except the polygons are not all regular—there is a rectangle in the place of the two squares—and the size of the polygons is changed. This lattice is in the isoradial representation in which each polygon is inscribed in a circle of unit radius. The two squares in the 2-uniform lattice must now be represented as a single rectangle in order to satisfy the isoradial condition. The lattice is shown by black edges, and the dual lattice by red dashed lines. The green circles show the isoradial constraint on both the original and dual lattices. The yellow polygons highlight the three types of polygons on the lattice, and the pink polygons highlight the two types of polygons on the dual lattice. The lattice has vertex types (Template:Frac)(33,42) + (Template:Frac)(3,4,6,4), while the dual lattice has vertex types (Template:Frac)(46)+(Template:Frac)(42,52)+(Template:Frac)(53)+(Template:Frac)(52,4). The critical point is where the longer bonds (on both the lattice and dual lattice) have occupation probability p = 2 sin (π/18) = 0.347296... which is the bond percolation threshold on a triangular lattice, and the shorter bonds have occupation probability 1 − 2 sin(π/18) = 0.652703..., which is the bond percolation on a hexagonal lattice. These results follow from the isoradial condition[70] but also follow from applying the star-triangle transformation to certain stars on the honeycomb lattice. Finally, it can be generalized to having three different probabilities in the three different directions, p1, p2 and p3 for the long bonds, and Template:Nowrap, Template:Nowrap, and Template:Nowrap for the short bonds, where p1, p2 and p3 satisfy the critical surface for the inhomogeneous triangular lattice.

Template:Clear

Thresholds on 2D bow-tie and martini lattices

To the left, center, and right are: the martini lattice, the martini-A lattice, the martini-B lattice. Below: the martini covering/medial lattice, same as the 2×2, 1×1 subnet for kagome-type lattices (removed).

Example image caption
Example image caption

Some other examples of generalized bow-tie lattices (a-d) and the duals of the lattices (e-h):

Example image caption
Example image caption
Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
martini (Template:Frac)(3,92)+(Template:Frac)(93) 3 3 0.764826..., 1 + p4 − 3p3 = 0[71] 0.707107... = 1/Template:Radic[72]
bow-tie (c) 3,4 3 Template:Frac 0.672929..., 1 − 2p3 − 2p4 − 2p5 − 7p6 + 18p7 + 11p8 − 35p9 + 21p10 − 4p11 = 0[73]
bow-tie (d) 3,4 3 Template:Frac 0.625457..., 1 − 2p2 − 3p3 + 4p4p5 = 0[73]
martini-A (Template:Frac)(3,72)+(Template:Frac)(3,73) 3,4 3 Template:Frac 1/Template:Radic[73] 0.625457..., 1 − 2p2 − 3p3 + 4p4p5 = 0[73]
bow-tie dual (e) 3,4 3 Template:Frac 0.595482..., 1-pcbond (bow-tie (a))[73]
bow-tie (b) 3,4,6 3 Template:Frac 0.533213..., 1 − p − 2p3 -4p4-4p5+156+ 13p7-36p8+19p9+ p10 + p11=0[73]
martini covering/medial (Template:Frac)(33,9) + (Template:Frac)(3,9,3,9) 4 4 0.707107... = 1/Template:Radic[72] 0.57086651(33)Template:Citation needed
martini-B (Template:Frac)(3,5,3,52) + (Template:Frac)(3,52) 3, 5 4 0.618034... = 2/(1 + Template:Radic), 1- p2p = 0[71][73] Template:Frac[72][73]
bow-tie dual (f) 3,4,8 4 Template:Frac 0.466787..., 1 − pcbond (bow-tie (b))[73]
bow-tie (a) (Template:Frac)(32,4,32,4) + (Template:Frac)(3,4,3) 4,6 5 0.5472(2),[38] 0.5479148(7)[74] 0.404518..., 1 − p − 6p2 + 6p3p5 = 0[73][75]
bow-tie dual (h) 3,6,8 5 0.374543..., 1 − pcbond(bow-tie (d))[73]
bow-tie dual (g) 3,6,10 5 Template:Frac 0.547... = pcsite(bow-tie(a)) 0.327071..., 1 − pcbond(bow-tie (c))[73]
martini dual (Template:Frac)(33) + (Template:Frac)(39) 3,9 6 Template:Frac 0.292893... = 1 − 1/Template:Radic[72]

Thresholds on 2D covering, medial, and matching lattices

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
(4, 6, 12) covering/medial 4 4 pcbond(4, 6, 12) = 0.693731... 0.5593140(2),[11] 0.559315(1)Template:Citation needed
(4, 82) covering/medial, square kagome 4 4 pcbond(4,82) = 0.676803... 0.544798017(4),[11] 0.54479793(34)Template:Citation needed
(34, 6) medial 4 4 0.5247495(5)[11]
(3,4,6,4) medial 4 4 0.51276[11]
(32, 4, 3, 4) medial 4 4 0.512682929(8)[11]
(33, 42) medial 4 4 0.5125245984(9)[11]
square covering (non-planar) 6 6 Template:Frac 0.3371(1)[56]
square matching lattice (non-planar) 8 8 1 − pcsite(square) = 0.407253... 0.25036834(6)[18]

Template:Multiple image

Template:Multiple image Template:Clear

Thresholds on 2D chimera non-planar lattices

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
K(2,2) 4 4 0.51253(14)[76] 0.44778(15)[76]
K(3,3) 6 6 0.43760(15)[76] 0.35502(15)[76]
K(4,4) 8 8 0.38675(7)[76] 0.29427(12)[76]
K(5,5) 10 10 0.35115(13)[76] 0.25159(13)[76]
K(6,6) 12 12 0.32232(13)[76] 0.21942(11)[76]
K(7,7) 14 14 0.30052(14)[76] 0.19475(9)[76]
K(8,8) 16 16 0.28103(11)[76] 0.17496(10)[76]

Thresholds on subnet lattices

Example image caption
Example image caption

The 2 x 2, 3 x 3, and 4 x 4 subnet kagome lattices. The 2 × 2 subnet is also known as the "triangular kagome" lattice.[77]

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
checkerboard – 2 × 2 subnet 4,3 0.596303(1)[78]
checkerboard – 4 × 4 subnet 4,3 0.633685(9)[78]
checkerboard – 8 × 8 subnet 4,3 0.642318(5)[78]
checkerboard – 16 × 16 subnet 4,3 0.64237(1)[78]
checkerboard – 32 × 32 subnet 4,3 0.64219(2)[78]
checkerboard – subnet 4,3 0.642216(10)[78]
kagome – 2 × 2 subnet = (3, 122) covering/medial 4 pcbond (3, 122) = 0.74042077... 0.600861966960(2),[11] 0.6008624(10),[19] 0.60086193(3)[9]
kagome – 3 × 3 subnet 4 0.6193296(10),[19] 0.61933176(5),[9] 0.61933044(32)Template:Citation needed
kagome – 4 × 4 subnet 4 0.625365(3),[19] 0.62536424(7)[9]
kagome – subnet 4 0.628961(2)[19]
kagome – (1 × 1):(2 × 2) subnet = martini covering/medial 4 pcbond(martini) = 1/Template:Radic = 0.707107... 0.57086648(36)Template:Citation needed
kagome – (1 × 1):(3 × 3) subnet 4,3 0.728355596425196...[9] 0.58609776(37)Template:Citation needed
kagome – (1 × 1):(4 × 4) subnet 0.738348473943256...[9]
kagome – (1 × 1):(5 × 5) subnet 0.743548682503071...[9]
kagome – (1 × 1):(6 × 6) subnet 0.746418147634282...[9]
kagome – (2 × 2):(3 × 3) subnet 0.61091770(30)Template:Citation needed
triangular – 2 × 2 subnet 6,4 0.471628788[78]
triangular – 3 × 3 subnet 6,4 0.509077793[78]
triangular – 4 × 4 subnet 6,4 0.524364822[78]
triangular – 5 × 5 subnet 6,4 0.5315976(10)[78]
triangular – subnet 6,4 0.53993(1)[78]

Thresholds of random sequentially adsorbed objects

(For more results and comparison to the jamming density, see Random sequential adsorption)

system z Site threshold
dimers on a honeycomb lattice 3 0.69,[79] 0.6653 [80]
dimers on a triangular lattice 6 0.4872(8),[79] 0.4873,[80]
aligned linear dimers on a triangular lattice 6 0.5157(2) [81]
aligned linear 4-mers on a triangular lattice 6 0.5220(2)[81]
aligned linear 8-mers on a triangular lattice 6 0.5281(5)[81]
aligned linear 12-mers on a triangular lattice 6 0.5298(8)[81]
linear 16-mers on a triangular lattice 6 aligned 0.5328(7)[81]
linear 32-mers on a triangular lattice 6 aligned 0.5407(6)[81]
linear 64-mers on a triangular lattice 6 aligned 0.5455(4)[81]
aligned linear 80-mers on a triangular lattice 6 0.5500(6)[81]
aligned linear k on a triangular lattice 6 0.582(9)[81]
dimers and 5% impurities, triangular lattice 6 0.4832(7)[82]
parallel dimers on a square lattice 4 0.5863[83]
dimers on a square lattice 4 0.5617,[83] 0.5618(1),[84] 0.562,[85] 0.5713[80]
linear 3-mers on a square lattice 4 0.528[85]
3-site 120° angle, 5% impurities, triangular lattice 6 0.4574(9)[82]
3-site triangles, 5% impurities, triangular lattice 6 0.5222(9)[82]
linear trimers and 5% impurities, triangular lattice 6 0.4603(8)[82]
linear 4-mers on a square lattice 4 0.504[85]
linear 5-mers on a square lattice 4 0.490[85]
linear 6-mers on a square lattice 4 0.479[85]
linear 8-mers on a square lattice 4 0.474,[85] 0.4697(1)[84]
linear 10-mers on a square lattice 4 0.469[85]
linear 16-mers on a square lattice 4 0.4639(1)[84]
linear 32-mers on a square lattice 4 0.4747(2)[84]

The threshold gives the fraction of sites occupied by the objects when site percolation first takes place (not at full jamming). For longer k-mers see Ref.[86]

Thresholds of full dimer coverings of two dimensional lattices

Here, we are dealing with networks that are obtained by covering a lattice with dimers, and then consider bond percolation on the remaining bonds. In discrete mathematics, this problem is known as the 'perfect matching' or the 'dimer covering' problem.

system z Bond threshold
Parallel covering, square lattice 6 0.381966...[87]
Shifted covering, square lattice 6 0.347296...[87]
Staggered covering, square lattice 6 0.376825(2)[87]
Random covering, square lattice 6 0.367713(2)[87]
Parallel covering, triangular lattice 10 0.237418...[87]
Staggered covering, triangular lattice 10 0.237497(2)[87]
Random covering, triangular lattice 10 0.235340(1)[87]

Thresholds of polymers (random walks) on a square lattice

System is composed of ordinary (non-avoiding) random walks of length l on the square lattice.[88]

l (polymer length) z Bond percolation
1 4 0.5(exact)[89]
2 4 0.47697(4)[89]
4 4 0.44892(6)[89]
8 4 0.41880(4)[89]

Thresholds of self-avoiding walks of length k added by random sequential adsorption

k z Site thresholds Bond thresholds
1 4 0.593(2)[90] 0.5009(2)[90]
2 4 0.564(2)[90] 0.4859(2)[90]
3 4 0.552(2)[90] 0.4732(2)[90]
4 4 0.542(2)[90] 0.4630(2)[90]
5 4 0.531(2)[90] 0.4565(2)[90]
6 4 0.522(2)[90] 0.4497(2)[90]
7 4 0.511(2)[90] 0.4423(2)[90]
8 4 0.502(2)[90] 0.4348(2)[90]
9 4 0.493(2)[90] 0.4291(2)[90]
10 4 0.488(2)[90] 0.4232(2)[90]
11 4 0.482(2)[90] 0.4159(2)[90]
12 4 0.476(2)[90] 0.4114(2)[90]
13 4 0.471(2)[90] 0.4061(2)[90]
14 4 0.467(2)[90] 0.4011(2)[90]
15 4 0.4011(2)[90] 0.3979(2)[90]

Thresholds on 2D inhomogeneous lattices

Lattice z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
bow-tie with p = Template:Frac on one non-diagonal bond 3 0.3819654(5),[91] (35)/2[56]

Thresholds for 2D continuum models

System Φc ηc nc
Disks of radius r 0.67634831(2),[92] 0.6763475(6),[93] 0.676339(4),[94] 0.6764(4),[95] 0.6766(5),[96] 0.676(2),[97] 0.679,[98] 0.674[99] 0.676,[100] 0.680[101] 1.1280867(5),[102] 1.1276(9),[103] 1.12808737(6),[92] 1.128085(2),[93] 1.128059(12),[94] 1.13,Template:Citation needed 0.8[104] 1.43632505(10),[105] 1.43632545(8),[92] 1.436322(2),[93] 1.436289(16),[94] 1.436320(4),[106] 1.436323(3),[107] 1.438(2),[108] 1.216 (48)[109]
Ellipses, ε = 1.5 0.0043[98] 0.00431 2.059081(7)[107]
Ellipses, ε = Template:Frac 0.65[110] 1.05[110] 2.28[110]
Ellipses, ε = 2 0.6287945(12),[107] 0.63[110] 0.991000(3),[107] 0.99[110] 2.523560(8),[107] 2.5[110]
Ellipses, ε = 3 0.56[110] 0.82[110] 3.157339(8),[107] 3.14[110]
Ellipses, ε = 4 0.5[110] 0.69[110] 3.569706(8),[107] 3.5[110]
Ellipses, ε = 5 0.455,[98] 0.455,[100] 0.46[110] 0.607[98] 3.861262(12),[107] 3.86[98]
Ellipses, ε = 6 4.079365(17)[107]
Ellipses, ε = 7 4.249132(16)[107]
Ellipses, ε = 8 4.385302(15)[107]
Ellipses, ε = 9 4.497000(8)[107]
Ellipses, ε = 10 0.301,[98] 0.303,[100] 0.30[110] 0.358[98] 0.36[110] 4.590416(23)[107] 4.56,[98] 4.5[110]
Ellipses, ε = 15 4.894752(30)[107]
Ellipses, ε = 20 0.178,[98] 0.17[110] 0.196[98] 5.062313(39),[107] 4.99[98]
Ellipses, ε = 50 0.081[98] 0.084[98] 5.393863(28),[107] 5.38[98]
Ellipses, ε = 100 0.0417[98] 0.0426[98] 5.513464(40),[107] 5.42[98]
Ellipses, ε = 200 0.021[110] 0.0212[110] 5.40[110]
Template:Nowrap 0.0043[98] 0.00431 5.624756(22),[107] 5.5
Superellipses, ε = 1, m = 1.5 0.671[100]
Superellipses, ε = 2.5, m = 1.5 0.599[100]
Superellipses, ε = 5, m = 1.5 0.469[100]
Superellipses, ε = 10, m = 1.5 0.322[100]
disco-rectangles, ε = 1.5 1.894 [106]
disco-rectangles, ε = 2 2.245 [106]
Aligned squares of side 0.66675(2),[52] 0.66674349(3),[92] 0.66653(1),[111] 0.6666(4),[112] 0.668[99] 1.09884280(9),[92] 1.0982(3),[111] 1.098(1)[112] 1.09884280(9),[92] 1.0982(3),[111] 1.098(1)[112]
Randomly oriented squares 0.62554075(4),[92] 0.6254(2)[112] 0.625,[100] 0.9822723(1),[92] 0.9819(6)[112] 0.982278(14)[113] 0.9822723(1),[92] 0.9819(6)[112] 0.982278(14)[113]
Randomly oriented squares within angle π/4 0.6255(1)[112] 0.98216(15)[112]
Rectangles, ε = 1.1 0.624870(7) 0.980484(19) 1.078532(21)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 2 0.590635(5) 0.893147(13) 1.786294(26)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 3 0.5405983(34) 0.777830(7) 2.333491(22)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 4 0.4948145(38) 0.682830(8) 2.731318(30)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 5 0.4551398(31), 0.451[100] 0.607226(6) 3.036130(28)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 10 0.3233507(25), 0.319[100] 0.3906022(37) 3.906022(37)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 20 0.2048518(22) 0.2292268(27) 4.584535(54)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 50 0.09785513(36) 0.1029802(4) 5.149008(20)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 100 0.0523676(6) 0.0537886(6) 5.378856(60)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 200 0.02714526(34) 0.02752050(35) 5.504099(69)[113]
Rectangles, ε = 1000 0.00559424(6) 0.00560995(6) 5.609947(60)[113]
Sticks (needles) of length 5.63726(2),[114] 5.6372858(6),[92] 5.637263(11),[113] 5.63724(18) [115]
sticks with log-normal length dist. STD=0.5 4.756(3) [115]
sticks with correlated angle dist. s=0.5 6.6076(4) [115]
Power-law disks, x = 2.05 0.993(1)[116] 4.90(1) 0.0380(6)
Power-law disks, x = 2.25 0.8591(5)[116] 1.959(5) 0.06930(12)
Power-law disks, x = 2.5 0.7836(4)[116] 1.5307(17) 0.09745(11)
Power-law disks, x = 4 0.69543(6)[116] 1.18853(19) 0.18916(3)
Power-law disks, x = 5 0.68643(13)[116] 1.1597(3) 0.22149(8)
Power-law disks, x = 6 0.68241(8)[116] 1.1470(1) 0.24340(5)
Power-law disks, x = 7 0.6803(8)[116] 1.140(6) 0.25933(16)
Power-law disks, x = 8 0.67917(9)[116] 1.1368(5) 0.27140(7)
Power-law disks, x = 9 0.67856(12)[116] 1.1349(4) 0.28098(9)
Voids around disks of radius r 1 − Φc(disk) = 0.32355169(2),[92] 0.318(2),[117] 0.3261(6)[118]
2D continuum percolation with disks
2D continuum percolation with ellipses of aspect ratio 2

For disks, nc=4r2N/L2 equals the critical number of disks per unit area, measured in units of the diameter 2r, where N is the number of objects and L is the system size

For disks, ηc=πr2N/L2=(π/4)nc equals critical total disk area.

4ηc gives the number of disk centers within the circle of influence (radius 2 r).

rc=LηcπN=L2ncN is the critical disk radius.

ηc=πabN/L2 for ellipses of semi-major and semi-minor axes of a and b, respectively. Aspect ratio ϵ=a/b with a>b.

ηc=mN/L2 for rectangles of dimensions and m. Aspect ratio ϵ=/m with >m.

ηc=πxN/(4L2(x2)) for power-law distributed disks with Prob(radiusR)=Rx, R1.

ϕc=1eηc equals critical area fraction.

For disks, Ref.[97] use ϕc=1eπx/2 where x is the density of disks of radius 1/2.

nc=2N/L2 equals number of objects of maximum length =2a per unit area.

For ellipses, nc=(4ϵ/π)ηc

For void percolation, ϕc=eηc is the critical void fraction.

For more ellipse values, see [107][110]

For more rectangle values, see [113]

Both ellipses and rectangles belong to the superellipses, with |x/a|2m+|y/b|2m=1. For more percolation values of superellipses, see.[100]

For the monodisperse particle systems, the percolation thresholds of concave-shaped superdisks are obtained as seen in [119]

For binary dispersions of disks, see [93][120][121]

Thresholds on 2D random and quasi-lattices

Voronoi diagram (solid lines) and its dual, the Delaunay triangulation (dotted lines), for a Poisson distribution of points
File:Delaunay triangulation example.png
Delaunay triangulation
The Voronoi covering or line graph (dotted red lines) and the Voronoi diagram (black lines)
The Relative Neighborhood Graph (black lines)[122] superimposed on the Delaunay triangulation (black plus grey lines).
The Gabriel Graph, a subgraph of the Delaunay triangulation in which the circle surrounding each edge does not enclose any other points of the graph
Uniform Infinite Planar Triangulation, showing bond clusters. From[123]
Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
Relative neighborhood graph 2.5576 0.796(2)[122] 0.771(2)[122]
Voronoi tessellation 3 0.71410(2),[124] 0.7151*[69] 0.68,[125] 0.6670(1),[126] 0.6680(5),[127] 0.666931(5)[124]
Voronoi covering/medial 4 0.666931(2)[124][126] 0.53618(2)[124]
Randomized kagome/square-octagon, fraction r=Template:Frac 4 0.6599[16]
Penrose rhomb dual 4 0.6381(3)[66] 0.5233(2)[66]
Gabriel graph 4 0.6348(8),[128] 0.62[129] 0.5167(6),[128] 0.52[129]
Random-line tessellation, dual 4 0.586(2)[130]
Penrose rhomb 4 0.5837(3),[66] 0.0.5610(6) (weighted bonds)[131] 0.58391(1)[132] 0.483(5),[133] 0.4770(2)[66]
Octagonal lattice, "chemical" links (Ammann–Beenker tiling) 4 0.585[134] 0.48[134]
Octagonal lattice, "ferromagnetic" links 5.17 0.543[134] 0.40[134]
Dodecagonal lattice, "chemical" links 3.63 0.628[134] 0.54[134]
Dodecagonal lattice, "ferromagnetic" links 4.27 0.617[134] 0.495[134]
Delaunay triangulation 6 Template:Frac[135] 0.3333(1)[126] 0.3326(5),[127] 0.333069(2)[124]
Uniform Infinite Planar Triangulation[136] 6 Template:Frac (2Template:Radic – 1)/11 ≈ 0.2240[123][137]

*Theoretical estimate

Thresholds on 2D correlated systems

Assuming power-law correlations C(r)|r|α

lattice α Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
square 3 0.561406(4)[138]
square 2 0.550143(5)[138]
square 0.1 0.508(4)[138]

Thresholds on slabs

h is the thickness of the slab, h × ∞ × ∞. Boundary conditions (b.c.) refer to the top and bottom planes of the slab.

Lattice h z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
simple cubic (open b.c.) 2 5 5 0.47424,[139] 0.4756[140]
bcc (open b.c.) 2 0.4155[140]
hcp (open b.c.) 2 0.2828[140]
diamond (open b.c.) 2 0.5451[140]
simple cubic (open b.c.) 3 0.4264[140]
bcc (open b.c.) 3 0.3531[140]
bcc (periodic b.c.) 3 0.21113018(38)[141]
hcp (open b.c.) 3 0.2548[140]
diamond (open b.c.) 3 0.5044[140]
simple cubic (open b.c.) 4 0.3997,[139] 0.3998[140]
bcc (open b.c.) 4 0.3232[140]
bcc (periodic b.c.) 4 0.20235168(59)[141]
hcp (open b.c.) 4 0.2405[140]
diamond (open b.c.) 4 0.4842[140]
simple cubic (periodic b.c.) 5 6 6 0.278102(5)[141]
simple cubic (open b.c.) 6 0.3708[140]
simple cubic (periodic b.c.) 6 6 6 0.272380(2)[141]
bcc (open b.c.) 6 0.2948[140]
hcp (open b.c.) 6 0.2261[140]
diamond (open b.c.) 6 0.4642[140]
simple cubic (periodic b.c.) 7 6 6 0.3459514(12)[141] 0.268459(1)[141]
simple cubic (open b.c.) 8 0.3557,[139] 0.3565[140]
simple cubic (periodic b.c.) 8 6 6 0.265615(5)[141]
bcc (open b.c.) 8 0.2811[140]
hcp (open b.c.) 8 0.2190[140]
diamond (open b.c.) 8 0.4549[140]
simple cubic (open b.c.) 12 0.3411[140]
bcc (open b.c.) 12 0.2688[140]
hcp (open b.c.) 12 0.2117[140]
diamond (open b.c.) 12 0.4456[140]
simple cubic (open b.c.) 16 0.3219,[139] 0.3339[140]
bcc (open b.c.) 16 0.2622[140]
hcp (open b.c.) 16 0.2086[140]
diamond (open b.c.) 16 0.4415[140]
simple cubic (open b.c.) 32 0.3219,[139]
simple cubic (open b.c.) 64 0.3165,[139]
simple cubic (open b.c.) 128 0.31398,[139]

Percolation in 3D

Lattice z z filling factor* filling fraction* Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
(10,3)-a oxide (or site-bond)[142] 23 32 2.4 0.748713(22)[142] = (pc,bond(10,3) – a)Template:Frac = 0.742334(25)[143]
(10,3)-b oxide (or site-bond)[142] 23 32 2.4 0.233[144] 0.174 0.745317(25)[142] = (pc,bond(10,3) – b)Template:Frac = 0.739388(22)[143]
silicon dioxide (diamond site-bond)[142] 4,22 2 Template:Frac 0.638683(35)[142]
Modified (10,3)-b[145] 32,2 2 Template:Frac 0.627[145]
(8,3)-a[143] 3 3 0.577962(33)[143] 0.555700(22)[143]
(10,3)-a[143] gyroid[146] 3 3 0.571404(40)[143] 0.551060(37)[143]
(10,3)-b[143] 3 3 0.565442(40)[143] 0.546694(33)[143]
cubic oxide (cubic site-bond)[142] 6,23 3.5 0.524652(50)[142]
bcc dual 4 0.4560(6)[147] 0.4031(6)[147]
ice Ih 4 4 π Template:Radic / 16 = 0.340087 0.147 0.433(11)[148] 0.388(10)[149]
diamond (Ice Ic) 4 4 π Template:Radic / 16 = 0.340087 0.1462332 0.4299(8),[150] 0.4299870(4),[151] Template:Val,[152] 0.4297(4) [153] 0.4301(4),[154] 0.428(4),[155] 0.425(15),[156] 0.425,[41][48] 0.436(12)[148] 0.3895892(5),[151] 0.3893(2),[154] 0.3893(3),[153] 0.388(5),[156] 0.3886(5),[150] 0.388(5)[155] 0.390(11)[149]
diamond dual 6 Template:Frac 0.3904(5)[147] 0.2350(5)[147]
3D kagome (covering graph of the diamond lattice) 6 π Template:Radic / 12 = 0.37024 0.1442 0.3895(2)[157] =pc(site) for diamond dual and pc(bond) for diamond lattice[147] 0.2709(6)[147]
Bow-tie stack dual 5 Template:Frac 0.3480(4)[38] 0.2853(4)[38]
honeycomb stack 5 5 0.3701(2)[38] 0.3093(2)[38]
octagonal stack dual 5 5 0.3840(4)[38] 0.3168(4)[38]
pentagonal stack 5 Template:Frac 0.3394(4)[38] 0.2793(4)[38]
kagome stack 6 6 0.453450 0.1517 0.3346(4)[38] 0.2563(2)[38]
fcc dual 42,8 5 Template:Frac 0.3341(5)[147] 0.2703(3)[147]
simple cubic 6 6 π / 6 = 0.5235988 0.1631574 0.307(10),[156] 0.307,[41] 0.3115(5),[158] 0.3116077(2),[159] 0.311604(6),[160] 0.311605(5),[161] 0.311600(5),[162] 0.3116077(4),[163] 0.3116081(13),[164] 0.3116080(4),[165] 0.3116060(48),[166] 0.3116004(35),[167] 0.31160768(15)[151] 0.247(5),[156] 0.2479(4),[150] 0.2488(2),[168] 0.24881182(10),[159] 0.2488125(25),[169] 0.2488126(5),[170]
hcp dual 44,82 5 Template:Frac 0.3101(5)[147] 0.2573(3)[147]
dice stack 5,8 6 π Template:Radic / 9 = 0.604600 0.1813 0.2998(4)[38] 0.2378(4)[38]
bow-tie stack 7 7 0.2822(6)[38] 0.2092(4)[38]
Stacked triangular / simple hexagonal 8 8 0.26240(5),[171] 0.2625(2),[172] 0.2623(2)[38] 0.18602(2),[171] 0.1859(2)[38]
octagonal (union-jack) stack 6,10 8 0.2524(6)[38] 0.1752(2)[38]
bcc 8 8 0.243(10),[156] 0.243,[41] 0.2459615(10),[165] 0.2460(3),[173] 0.2464(7),[150] 0.2458(2)[154] 0.178(5),[156] 0.1795(3),[150] 0.18025(15),[168] 0.1802875(10)[170]
simple cubic with 3NN (same as bcc) 8 8 0.2455(1),[174] 0.2457(7)[175]
fcc, D3 12 12 π / (3 Template:Radic) = 0.740480 0.147530 0.195,[41] 0.198(3),[176] 0.1998(6),[150] 0.1992365(10),[165] 0.19923517(20),[151] 0.1994(2),[154] 0.199236(4)[177] 0.1198(3),[150] 0.1201635(10)[170] 0.120169(2)[177]
hcp 12 12 π / (3 Template:Radic) = 0.740480 0.147545 0.195(5),[156] 0.1992555(10)[178] 0.1201640(10),[178] 0.119(2)[156]
La2−x Srx Cu O4 12 12 0.19927(2)[179]
simple cubic with 2NN (same as fcc) 12 12 0.1991(1)[174]
simple cubic with NN+4NN 12 12 0.15040(12),[180] 0.1503793(7)[181] 0.1068263(7)[182]
simple cubic with 3NN+4NN 14 14 0.20490(12)[180] 0.1012133(7)[182]
bcc NN+2NN (= sc(3,4) sc-3NN+4NN) 14 14 0.175,[41] 0.1686,(20)[183] 0.1759432(8) 0.0991(5),[183] 0.1012133(7),[45] 0.1759432(8) [45]
Nanotube fibers on FCC 14 14 0.1533(13)[184]
simple cubic with NN+3NN 14 14 0.1420(1)[174] 0.0920213(7)[182]
simple cubic with 2NN+4NN 18 18 0.15950(12)[180] 0.0751589(9)[182]
simple cubic with NN+2NN 18 18 0.137,[48] 0.136,[185] 0.1372(1),[174] 0.13735(5),Template:Citation needed 0.1373045(5)[45] 0.0752326(6) [182]
fcc with NN+2NN (=sc-2NN+4NN) 18 18 0.136,[41] 0.1361408(8)[45] 0.0751589(9) [45]
simple cubic with short-length correlation 6+ 6+ 0.126(1)[186]
simple cubic with NN+3NN+4NN 20 20 0.11920(12)[180] 0.0624379(9)[182]
simple cubic with 2NN+3NN 20 20 0.1036(1)[174] 0.0629283(7)[182]
simple cubic with NN+2NN+4NN 24 24 0.11440(12)[180] 0.0533056(6)[182]
simple cubic with 2NN+3NN+4NN 26 26 0.11330(12)[180] 0.0474609(9)
simple cubic with NN+2NN+3NN 26 26 0.097,[41] 0.0976(1),[174] 0.0976445(10), 0.0976444(6)[45] 0.0497080(10)[182]
bcc with NN+2NN+3NN 26 26 0.095,[48] 0.0959084(6)[45] 0.0492760(10)[45]
simple cubic with NN+2NN+3NN+4NN 32 32 0.10000(12),[180] 0.0801171(9)[45] 0.0392312(8)[182]
fcc with NN+2NN+3NN 42 42 0.061,[48] 0.0610(5),[185] 0.0618842(8)[45] 0.0290193(7) [45]
fcc with NN+2NN+3NN+4NN 54 54 0.0500(5)[185]
sc-1,2,3,4,5 simple cubic with NN+2NN+3NN+4NN+5NN 56 56 0.0461815(5)[45] 0.0210977(7)[45]
sc-1,...,6 (2x2x2 cube [51]) 80 80 0.0337049(9),[45] 0.03373(13)[51] 0.0143950(10)[45]
sc-1,...,7 92 92 0.0290800(10)[45] 0.0123632(8)[45]
sc-1,...,8 122 122 0.0218686(6)[45] 0.0091337(7)[45]
sc-1,...,9 146 146 0.0184060(10)[45] 0.0075532(8)[45]
sc-1,...,10 170 170 0.0064352(8)[45]
sc-1,...,11 178 178 0.0061312(8)[45]
sc-1,...,12 202 202 0.0053670(10)[45]
sc-1,...,13 250 250 0.0042962(8)[45]
3x3x3 cube 274 274 φc= 0.76564(1),[52] pc = 0.0098417(7),[52] 0.009854(6)[51]
4x4x4 cube 636 636 φc=0.76362(1),[52] pc = 0.0042050(2),[52] 0.004217(3)[51]
5x5x5 cube 1214 1250 φc=0.76044(2),[52] pc = 0.0021885(2),[52] 0.002185(4)[51]
6x6x6 cube 2056 2056 0.001289(2)[51]

Filling factor = fraction of space filled by touching spheres at every lattice site (for systems with uniform bond length only). Also called Atomic Packing Factor.

Filling fraction (or Critical Filling Fraction) = filling factor * pc(site).

NN = nearest neighbor, 2NN = next-nearest neighbor, 3NN = next-next-nearest neighbor, etc.

kxkxk cubes are cubes of occupied sites on a lattice, and are equivalent to extended-range percolation of a cube of length (2k+1), with edges and corners removed, with z = (2k+1)3-12(2k-1)-9 (center site not counted in z).

Question: the bond thresholds for the hcp and fcc lattice agree within the small statistical error. Are they identical, and if not, how far apart are they? Which threshold is expected to be bigger? Similarly for the ice and diamond lattices. See [187]

System polymer Φc
percolating excluded volume of athermal polymer matrix (bond-fluctuation model on cubic lattice) 0.4304(3)[188]

3D distorted lattices

Here, one distorts a regular lattice of unit spacing by moving vertices uniformly within the cube (xα,x+α),(yα,y+α),(zα,z+α), and considers percolation when sites are within Euclidean distance d of each other.

Lattice z α d Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
cubic 0.05 1.0 0.60254(3)[189]
0.1 1.00625 0.58688(4)[189]
0.15 1.025 0.55075(2)[189]
0.175 1.05 0.50645(5)[189]
0.2 1.1 0.44342(3)[189]

Overlapping shapes on 3D lattices

Site threshold is the number of overlapping objects per lattice site. The coverage φc is the net fraction of sites covered, and v is the volume (number of cubes). Overlapping cubes are given in the section on thresholds of 3D lattices. Here z is the coordination number to k-mers of either orientation, with z=6k2+18k4

System k z Site coverage φc Site percolation threshold pc
1 x 2 dimer, cubic lattice 2 56 0.24542[51] 0.045847(2)[51]
1 x 3 trimer, cubic lattice 3 104 0.19578[51] 0.023919(9)[51]
1 x 4 stick, cubic lattice 4 164 0.16055[51] 0.014478(7)[51]
1 x 5 stick, cubic lattice 5 236 0.13488[51] 0.009613(8)[51]
1 x 6 stick, cubic lattice 6 320 0.11569[51] 0.006807(2)[51]
2 x 2 plaquette, cubic lattice 2 0.22710[51] 0.021238(2)[51]
3 x 3 plaquette, cubic lattice 3 0.18686[51] 0.007632(5)[51]
4 x 4 plaquette, cubic lattice 4 0.16159[51] 0.003665(3)[51]
5 x 5 plaquette, cubic lattice 5 0.14316[51] 0.002058(5)[51]
6 x 6 plaquette, cubic lattice 6 0.12900[51] 0.001278(5)[51]

The coverage is calculated from pc by ϕc=1(1pc)3k for sticks, and ϕc=1(1pc)3k2 for plaquettes.

Dimer percolation in 3D

System Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
Simple cubic 0.2555(1)[190]

Thresholds for 3D continuum models

All overlapping except for jammed spheres and polymer matrix.

System Φc ηc
Spheres of radius r 0.289,[191] 0.293,[192] 0.286,[193] 0.295.[99] 0.2895(5),[194] 0.28955(7),[195] 0.2896(7),[196] 0.289573(2),[197] 0.2896,[198] 0.2854,[199] 0.290,[200] 0.290[201] 0.3418(7),[194] 0.3438(13),[202] 0.341889(3),[197] 0.3360,[199] 0.34189(2) [111] [corrected], 0.341935(8),[203] 0.335,[204]
Oblate ellipsoids with major radius r and aspect ratio Template:Frac 0.2831[199] 0.3328[199]
Prolate ellipsoids with minor radius r and aspect ratio Template:Frac 0.2757,[198] 0.2795,[199] 0.2763[200] 0.3278[199]
Oblate ellipsoids with major radius r and aspect ratio 2 0.2537,[198] 0.2629,[199] 0.254[200] 0.3050[199]
Prolate ellipsoids with minor radius r and aspect ratio 2 0.2537,[198] 0.2618,[199] 0.25(2),[205] 0.2507[200] 0.3035,[199] 0.29(3)[205]
Oblate ellipsoids with major radius r and aspect ratio 3 0.2289[199] 0.2599[199]
Prolate ellipsoids with minor radius r and aspect ratio 3 0.2033,[198] 0.2244,[199] 0.20(2)[205] 0.2541,[199] 0.22(3)[205]
Oblate ellipsoids with major radius r and aspect ratio 4 0.2003[199] 0.2235[199]
Prolate ellipsoids with minor radius r and aspect ratio 4 0.1901,[199] 0.16(2)[205] 0.2108,[199] 0.17(3)[205]
Oblate ellipsoids with major radius r and aspect ratio 5 0.1757[199] 0.1932[199]
Prolate ellipsoids with minor radius r and aspect ratio 5 0.1627,[199] 0.13(2)[205] 0.1776,[199] 0.15(2)[205]
Oblate ellipsoids with major radius r and aspect ratio 10 0.0895,[198] 0.1058[199] 0.1118[199]
Prolate ellipsoids with minor radius r and aspect ratio 10 0.0724,[198] 0.08703,[199] 0.07(2)[205] 0.09105,[199] 0.07(2)[205]
Oblate ellipsoids with major radius r and aspect ratio 100 0.01248[199] 0.01256[199]
Prolate ellipsoids with minor radius r and aspect ratio 100 0.006949[199] 0.006973[199]
Oblate ellipsoids with major radius r and aspect ratio 1000 0.001275[199] 0.001276[199]
Oblate ellipsoids with major radius r and aspect ratio 2000 0.000637[199] 0.000637[199]
Spherocylinders with H/D = 1 0.2439(2)[196]
Spherocylinders with H/D = 4 0.1345(1)[196]
Spherocylinders with H/D = 10 0.06418(20)[196]
Spherocylinders with H/D = 50 0.01440(8)[196]
Spherocylinders with H/D = 100 0.007156(50)[196]
Spherocylinders with H/D = 200 0.003724(90)[196]
Aligned cylinders 0.2819(2)[206] 0.3312(1)[206]
Aligned cubes of side =2a 0.2773(2)[112] 0.27727(2),[52] 0.27730261(79)[166] 0.3247(3),[111] 0.3248(3),[112] 0.32476(4)[206] 0.324766(1)[166]
Randomly oriented icosahedra 0.3030(5)[207]
Randomly oriented dodecahedra 0.2949(5)[207]
Randomly oriented octahedra 0.2514(6)[207]
Randomly oriented cubes of side =2a 0.2168(2)[112] 0.2174,[198] 0.2444(3),[112] 0.2443(5)[207]
Randomly oriented tetrahedra 0.1701(7)[207]
Randomly oriented disks of radius r (in 3D) 0.9614(5)[208]
Randomly oriented square plates of side πr 0.8647(6)[208]
Randomly oriented triangular plates of side 2π/31/4r 0.7295(6)[208]
Jammed spheres (average z = 6) 0.183(3),[209] 0.1990,[210] see also contact network of jammed spheres below. 0.59(1)[209] (volume fraction of all spheres)

ηc=(4/3)πr3N/L3 is the total volume (for spheres), where N is the number of objects and L is the system size.

ϕc=1eηc is the critical volume fraction, valid for overlapping randomly placed objects.

For disks and plates, these are effective volumes and volume fractions.

For void ("Swiss-Cheese" model), ϕc=eηc is the critical void fraction.

For more results on void percolation around ellipsoids and elliptical plates, see.[211]

For more ellipsoid percolation values see.[199]

For spherocylinders, H/D is the ratio of the height to the diameter of the cylinder, which is then capped by hemispheres. Additional values are given in.[196]

For superballs, m is the deformation parameter, the percolation values are given in.,[212][213] In addition, the thresholds of concave-shaped superballs are also determined in [119]

For cuboid-like particles (superellipsoids), m is the deformation parameter, more percolation values are given in.[198]

Void percolation in 3D

Void percolation refers to percolation in the space around overlapping objects. Here ϕc refers to the fraction of the space occupied by the voids (not of the particles) at the critical point, and is related to ηc by ϕc=eηc. ηc is defined as in the continuum percolation section above.

System Φc ηc
Voids around disks of radius r 22.86(2)[211]
Voids around randomly oriented tetrahedra 0.0605(6)[214]
Voids around oblate ellipsoids of major radius r and aspect ratio 32 0.5308(7)[215] 0.6333[215]
Voids around oblate ellipsoids of major radius r and aspect ratio 16 0.3248(5)[215] 1.125[215]
Voids around oblate ellipsoids of major radius r and aspect ratio 10 1.542(1)[211]
Voids around oblate ellipsoids of major radius r and aspect ratio 8 0.1615(4)[215] 1.823[215]
Voids around oblate ellipsoids of major radius r and aspect ratio 4 0.0711(2)[215] 2.643,[215] 2.618(5)[211]
Voids around oblate ellipsoids of major radius r and aspect ratio 2 3.239(4) [211]
Voids around prolate ellipsoids of aspect ratio 8 0.0415(7)[216]
Voids around prolate ellipsoids of aspect ratio 6 0.0397(7)[216]
Voids around prolate ellipsoids of aspect ratio 4 0.0376(7)[216]
Voids around prolate ellipsoids of aspect ratio 3 0.03503(50)[216]
Voids around prolate ellipsoids of aspect ratio 2 0.0323(5)[216]
Voids around aligned square prisms of aspect ratio 2 0.0379(5) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 20 0.0534(4) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 15 0.0535(4) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 10 0.0524(5) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 8 0.0523(6) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 7 0.0519(3) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 6 0.0519(5) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 5 0.0515(7) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 4 0.0505(7) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 3 0.0485(11) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 5/2 0.0483(8) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 2 0.0465(7) [217]
Voids around randomly oriented square prisms of aspect ratio 3/2 0.0461(14) [217]
Voids around hemispheres 0.0455(6)[218]
Voids around aligned tetrahedra 0.0605(6)[214]
Voids around randomly oriented tetrahedra 0.0605(6)[214]
Voids around aligned cubes 0.036(1),[52] 0.0381(3)[214]
Voids around randomly oriented cubes 0.0452(6),[214] 0.0449(5)[217]
Voids around aligned octahedra 0.0407(3)[214]
Voids around randomly oriented octahedra 0.0398(5)[214]
Voids around aligned dodecahedra 0.0356(3)[214]
Voids around randomly oriented dodecahedra 0.0360(3)[214]
Voids around aligned icosahedra 0.0346(3)[214]
Voids around randomly oriented icosahedra 0.0336(7)[214]
Voids around spheres 0.034(7),[219] 0.032(4),[220] 0.030(2),[117] 0.0301(3),[221] 0.0294,[216] 0.0300(3),[222] 0.0317(4),[223] 0.0308(5)[218] 0.0301(1),[215] 0.0301(1)[214] 3.506(8),[222] 3.515(6),[211] 3.510(2)[103]

Thresholds on 3D random and quasi-lattices

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
Contact network of packed spheres 6 0.310(5),[209] 0.287(50),[224] 0.3116(3),[210]
Random-plane tessellation, dual 6 0.290(7)[225]
Icosahedral Penrose 6 0.285[226] 0.225[226]
Penrose w/2 diagonals 6.764 0.271[226] 0.207[226]
Penrose w/8 diagonals 12.764 0.188[226] 0.111[226]
Voronoi network 15.54 0.1453(20)[183] 0.0822(50)[183]

Thresholds for other 3D models

Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Critical coverage fraction ϕc Bond percolation threshold
Drilling percolation, simple cubic lattice* 6 6 0.6345(3),[227] 0.6339(5),[228] 0.633965(15)[229] 0.25480
Drill in z direction on cubic lattice, remove single sites 6 6 0.592746 (columns), 0.4695(10) (sites)[230] 0.2784
Random tube model, simple cubic lattice 0.231456(6)[231]
Pac-Man percolation, simple cubic lattice 0.139(6)[232]

In drilling percolation, the site threshold pc represents the fraction of columns in each direction that have not been removed, and ϕc=pc3. For the 1d drilling, we have ϕc=pc(columns) pc(sites).

In tube percolation, the bond threshold represents the value of the parameter μ such that the probability of putting a bond between neighboring vertical tube segments is 1eμhi, where hi is the overlap height of two adjacent tube segments.[231]

Thresholds in different dimensional spaces

Continuum models in higher dimensions

d System Φc ηc
4 Overlapping hyperspheres 0.1223(4)[111] 0.1300(13),[202] 0.1304(5)[111]
4 Aligned hypercubes 0.1132(5),[111] 0.1132348(17) [166] 0.1201(6)[111]
4 Voids around hyperspheres 0.00211(2)[118] 6.161(10)[118] 6.248(2),[103]
5 Overlapping hyperspheres 0.0544(6),[202] 0.05443(7)[111]
5 Aligned hypercubes 0.04900(7),[111] 0.0481621(13)[166] 0.05024(7)[111]
5 Voids around hyperspheres 1.26(6)x10−4[118] 8.98(4),[118] 9.170(8)[103]
6 Overlapping hyperspheres 0.02391(31),[202] 0.02339(5)[111]
6 Aligned hypercubes 0.02082(8),[111] 0.0213479(10)[166] 0.02104(8)[111]
6 Voids around hyperspheres 8.0(6)x10−6 [118] 11.74(8),[118] 12.24(2),[103]
7 Overlapping hyperspheres 0.01102(16),[202] 0.01051(3)[111]
7 Aligned hypercubes 0.00999(5),[111] 0.0097754(31)[166] 0.01004(5)[111]
7 Voids around hyperspheres 15.46(5)[103]
8 Overlapping hyperspheres 0.00516(8),[202] 0.004904(6)[111]
8 Aligned hypercubes 0.004498(5)[111]
8 Voids around hyperspheres 18.64(8)[103]
9 Overlapping hyperspheres 0.002353(4)[111]
9 Aligned hypercubes 0.002166(4)[111]
9 Voids around hyperspheres 22.1(4)[103]
10 Overlapping hyperspheres 0.001138(3)[111]
10 Aligned hypercubes 0.001058(4)[111]
11 Overlapping hyperspheres 0.0005530(3)[111]
11 Aligned hypercubes 0.0005160(3)[111]

ηc=(πd/2/Γ[d/2+1])rdN/Ld.

In 4d, ηc=(1/2)π2r4N/L4.

In 5d, ηc=(8/15)π2r5N/L5.

In 6d, ηc=(1/6)π3r6N/L6.

ϕc=1eηc is the critical volume fraction, valid for overlapping objects.

For void models, ϕc=eηc is the critical void fraction, and ηc is the total volume of the overlapping objects

Thresholds on hypercubic lattices

d z Site thresholds Bond thresholds
4 8 0.198(1)[233] 0.197(6),[234] 0.1968861(14),[235] 0.196889(3),[236] 0.196901(5),[237] 0.19680(23),[238] 0.1968904(65),[166] 0.19688561(3)[239] 0.1600(1),[240] 0.16005(15),[168] 0.1601314(13),[235] 0.160130(3),[236] 0.1601310(10),[169] 0.1601312(2),[241] 0.16013122(6)[239]
5 10 0.141(1),0.198(1)[233] 0.141(3),[234] 0.1407966(15),[235] 0.1407966(26),[166] 0.14079633(4)[239] 0.1181(1),[240] 0.118(1),[242] 0.11819(4),[168] 0.118172(1),[235] 0.1181718(3)[169] 0.11817145(3)[239]
6 12 0.106(1),[233] 0.108(3),[234] 0.109017(2),[235] 0.1090117(30),[166] 0.109016661(8)[239] 0.0943(1),[240] 0.0942(1),[243] 0.0942019(6),[235] 0.09420165(2)[239]
7 14 0.05950(5),[243] 0.088939(20),[244] 0.0889511(9),[235] 0.0889511(90),[166] 0.088951121(1),[239] 0.0787(1),[240] 0.078685(30),[243] 0.0786752(3),[235] 0.078675230(2)[239]
8 16 0.0752101(5),[235] 0.075210128(1)[239] 0.06770(5),[243] 0.06770839(7),[235] 0.0677084181(3)[239]
9 18 0.0652095(3),[235] 0.0652095348(6)[239] 0.05950(5),[243] 0.05949601(5),[235] 0.0594960034(1)[239]
10 20 0.0575930(1),[235] 0.0575929488(4)[239] 0.05309258(4),[235] 0.0530925842(2)[239]
11 22 0.05158971(8),[235] 0.0515896843(2)[239] 0.04794969(1),[235] 0.04794968373(8)[239]
12 24 0.04673099(6),[235] 0.0467309755(1)[239] 0.04372386(1),[235] 0.04372385825(10)[239]
13 26 0.04271508(8),[235] 0.04271507960(10)[239] 0.04018762(1),[235] 0.04018761703(6)[239]

For thresholds on high dimensional hypercubic lattices, we have the asymptotic series expansions [234] [242] [245]

pcsite(d)=σ1+32σ2+154σ3+834σ4+657748σ5+11907796σ6+𝒪(σ7)

pcbond(d)=σ1+52σ3+152σ4+57σ5+485512σ6+𝒪(σ7)

where σ=2d1. For 13-dimensional bond percolation, for example, the error with the measured value is less than 10−6, and these formulas can be useful for higher-dimensional systems.

Thresholds in other higher-dimensional lattices

d lattice z Site thresholds Bond thresholds
4 diamond 5 0.2978(2)[154] 0.2715(3)[154]
4 kagome 8 0.2715(3)[157] 0.177(1) [154]
4 bcc 16 0.1037(3)[154] 0.074(1),[154] 0.074212(1)[241]
4 fcc, D4, hypercubic 2NN 24 0.0842(3),[154] 0.08410(23),[238] 0.0842001(11)[177] 0.049(1),[154] 0.049517(1),[241] 0.0495193(8)[177]
4 hypercubic NN+2NN 32 0.06190(23),[238] 0.0617731(19)[246] 0.035827(1),[241] 0.0338047(27)[246]
4 hypercubic 3NN 32 0.04540(23)[238]
4 hypercubic NN+3NN 40 0.04000(23)[238] 0.0271892(22)[246]
4 hypercubic 2NN+3NN 56 0.03310(23)[238] 0.0194075(15)[246]
4 hypercubic NN+2NN+3NN 64 0.03190(23),[238] 0.0319407(13)[246] 0.0171036(11)[246]
4 hypercubic NN+2NN+3NN+4NN 88 0.0231538(12)[246] 0.0122088(8)[246]
4 hypercubic NN+...+5NN 136 0.0147918(12)[246] 0.0077389(9)[246]
4 hypercubic NN+...+6NN 232 0.0088400(10)[246] 0.0044656(11)[246]
4 hypercubic NN+...+7NN 296 0.0070006(6)[246] 0.0034812(7)[246]
4 hypercubic NN+...+8NN 320 0.0064681(9)[246] 0.0032143(8)[246]
4 hypercubic NN+...+9NN 424 0.0048301(9)[246] 0.0024117(7)[246]
5 diamond 6 0.2252(3)[154] 0.2084(4)[157]
5 kagome 10 0.2084(4)[157] 0.130(2)[154]
5 bcc 32 0.0446(4)[154] 0.033(1)[154]
5 fcc, D5, hypercubic 2NN 40 0.0431(3),[154] 0.0435913(6)[177] 0.026(2),[154] 0.0271813(2)[177]
5 hypercubic NN+2NN 50 0.0334(2)[247] 0.0213(1)[247]
6 diamond 7 0.1799(5)[154] 0.1677(7)[157]
6 kagome 12 0.1677(7)[157]
6 fcc, D6 60 0.0252(5),[154] 0.02602674(12)[177] 0.01741556(5)[177]
6 bcc 64 0.0199(5)[154]
6 E6[177] 72 0.02194021(14)[177] 0.01443205(8)[177]
7 fcc, D7 84 0.01716730(5)[177] 0.012217868(13)[177]
7 E7[177] 126 0.01162306(4)[177] 0.00808368(2)[177]
8 fcc, D8 112 0.01215392(4)[177] 0.009081804(6)[177]
8 E8[177] 240 0.00576991(2)[177] 0.004202070(2)[177]
9 fcc, D9 144 0.00905870(2)[177] 0.007028457(3)[177]
9 Λ9[177] 272 0.00480839(2)[177] 0.0037006865(11)[177]
10 fcc, D10 180 0.007016353(9)[177] 0.005605579(6)[177]
11 fcc, D11 220 0.005597592(4)[177] 0.004577155(3)[177]
12 fcc, D12 264 0.004571339(4)[177] 0.003808960(2)[177]
13 fcc, D13 312 0.003804565(3)[177] 0.0032197013(14)[177]

Thresholds in one-dimensional long-range percolation

Long-range bond percolation model. The lines represent the possible bonds with width decreasing as the connection probability decreases (left panel). An instance of the model together with the clusters generated (right panel).

In a one-dimensional chain we establish bonds between distinct sites i and j with probability p=C|ij|1+σ decaying as a power-law with an exponent σ>0. Percolation occurs[248][249] at a critical value Cc<1 for σ<1. The numerically determined percolation thresholds are given by:[250]

σ Cc Critical thresholds Cc as a function of σ.[250]
The dotted line is the rigorous lower bound.[248]
0.1 0.047685(8)
0.2 0.093211(16)
0.3 0.140546(17)
0.4 0.193471(15)
0.5 0.25482(5)
0.6 0.327098(6)
0.7 0.413752(14)
0.8 0.521001(14)
0.9 0.66408(7)

Template:Clear

Thresholds on hyperbolic, hierarchical, and tree lattices

In these lattices there may be two percolation thresholds: the lower threshold is the probability above which infinite clusters appear, and the upper is the probability above which there is a unique infinite cluster.

Visualization of a triangular hyperbolic lattice {3,7} projected on the Poincaré disk (red bonds). Green bonds show dual-clusters on the {7,3} lattice[251]
Depiction of the non-planar Hanoi network HN-NP[252]
Lattice z z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
Lower Upper Lower Upper
{3,7} hyperbolic 7 7 0.26931171(7),[253] 0.20[254] 0.73068829(7),[253] 0.73(2)[254] 0.20,[255] 0.1993505(5)[253] 0.37,[255] 0.4694754(8)[253]
{3,8} hyperbolic 8 8 0.20878618(9)[253] 0.79121382(9)[253] 0.1601555(2)[253] 0.4863559(6)[253]
{3,9} hyperbolic 9 9 0.1715770(1)[253] 0.8284230(1)[253] 0.1355661(4)[253] 0.4932908(1)[253]
{4,5} hyperbolic 5 5 0.29890539(6)[253] 0.8266384(5)[253] 0.27,[255] 0.2689195(3)[253] 0.52,[255] 0.6487772(3) [253]
{4,6} hyperbolic 6 6 0.22330172(3)[253] 0.87290362(7)[253] 0.20714787(9)[253] 0.6610951(2)[253]
{4,7} hyperbolic 7 7 0.17979594(1)[253] 0.89897645(3)[253] 0.17004767(3)[253] 0.66473420(4)[253]
{4,8} hyperbolic 8 8 0.151035321(9)[253] 0.91607962(7)[253] 0.14467876(3)[253] 0.66597370(3)[253]
{4,9} hyperbolic 8 8 0.13045681(3)[253] 0.92820305(3)[253] 0.1260724(1)[253] 0.66641596(2)[253]
{5,5} hyperbolic 5 5 0.26186660(5)[253] 0.89883342(7)[253] 0.263(10),[256] 0.25416087(3)[253] 0.749(10)[256] 0.74583913(3)[253]
{7,3} hyperbolic 3 3 0.54710885(10)[253] 0.8550371(5),[253] 0.86(2)[254] 0.53,[255] 0.551(10),[256] 0.5305246(8)[253] 0.72,[255] 0.810(10),[256] 0.8006495(5)[253]
{∞,3} Cayley tree 3 3 Template:Frac Template:Frac[255] 1[255]
Enhanced binary tree (EBT) 0.304(1),[257] 0.306(10),[256] (Template:Radic − 3)/2 = 0.302776[258] 0.48,[255] 0.564(1),[257] 0.564(10),[256] Template:Frac[258]
Enhanced binary tree dual 0.436(1),[257] 0.452(10)[256] 0.696(1),[257] 0.699(10)[256]
Non-Planar Hanoi Network (HN-NP) 0.319445[252] 0.381996[252]
Cayley tree with grandparents 8 0.158656326[259]

Note: {m,n} is the Schläfli symbol, signifying a hyperbolic lattice in which n regular m-gons meet at every vertex

For bond percolation on {P,Q}, we have by duality pc,(P,Q)+pc,u(Q,P)=1. For site percolation, pc,(3,Q)+pc,u(3,Q)=1 because of the self-matching of triangulated lattices.

Cayley tree (Bethe lattice) with coordination number z:pc=1/(z1)

Thresholds for directed percolation

(1+1)D Kagome Lattice
(1+1)D Square Lattice
(1+1)D Triangular Lattice
(2+1)D SC Lattice
(2+1)D BCC Lattice
Lattice z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
(1+1)-d honeycomb 1.5 0.8399316(2),[260] 0.839933(5),[261] =pc(site) of (1+1)-d sq. 0.8228569(2),[260] 0.82285680(6)[260]
(1+1)-d kagome 2 0.7369317(2),[260] 0.73693182(4)[262] 0.6589689(2),[260] 0.65896910(8)[260]
(1+1)-d square, diagonal 2 0.705489(4),[263] 0.705489(4),[264] 0.70548522(4),[265] 0.70548515(20),[262] 0.7054852(3),[260] 0.644701(2),[266] 0.644701(1),[267] 0.644701(1),[263] 0.6447006(10),[261] 0.64470015(5),[268] 0.644700185(5),[265] 0.6447001(2),[260] 0.643(2)[269]
(1+1)-d triangular 3 0.595646(3),[263] 0.5956468(5),[268] 0.5956470(3)[260] 0.478018(2),[263] 0.478025(1),[268] 0.4780250(4)[260] 0.479(3)[269]
(2+1)-d simple cubic, diagonal planes 3 0.43531(1),[270] 0.43531411(10)[260] 0.382223(7),[270] 0.38222462(6)[260] 0.383(3)[269]
(2+1)-d square nn (= bcc) 4 0.3445736(3),[271] 0.344575(15)[272] 0.3445740(2)[260] 0.2873383(1),[273] 0.287338(3)[270] 0.28733838(4)[260] 0.287(3)[269]
(2+1)-d fcc 0.199(2))[269]
(3+1)-d hypercubic, diagonal 4 0.3025(10),[274] 0.30339538(5) [260] 0.26835628(5),[260] 0.2682(2)[269]
(3+1)-d cubic, nn 6 0.2081040(4)[271] 0.1774970(5)[169]
(3+1)-d bcc 8 0.160950(30),[272] 0.16096128(3)[260] 0.13237417(2)[260]
(4+1)-d hypercubic, diagonal 5 0.23104686(3)[260] 0.20791816(2),[260] 0.2085(2)[269]
(4+1)-d hypercubic, nn 8 0.1461593(2),[271] 0.1461582(3)[275] 0.1288557(5)[169]
(4+1)-d bcc 16 0.075582(17),[272] 0.0755850(3),[275] 0.07558515(1)[260] 0.063763395(5)[260]
(5+1)-d hypercubic, diagonal 6 0.18651358(2)[260] 0.170615155(5),[260] 0.1714(1) [269]
(5+1)-d hypercubic, nn 10 0.1123373(2)[271] 0.1016796(5)[169]
(5+1)-d hypercubic bcc 32 0.035967(23),[272] 0.035972540(3)[260] 0.0314566318(5)[260]
(6+1)-d hypercubic, diagonal 7 0.15654718(1)[260] 0.145089946(3),[260] 0.1458[269]
(6+1)-d hypercubic, nn 12 0.0913087(2)[271] 0.0841997(14)[169]
(6+1)-d hypercubic bcc 64 0.017333051(2)[260] 0.01565938296(10)[260]
(7+1)-d hypercubic, diagonal 8 0.135004176(10)[260] 0.126387509(3),[260] 0.1270(1) [269]
(7+1)-d hypercubic,nn 14 0.07699336(7)[271] 0.07195(5)[169]
(7+1)-d bcc 128 0.008 432 989(2)[260] 0.007 818 371 82(6)[260]

nn = nearest neighbors. For a (d + 1)-dimensional hypercubic system, the hypercube is in d dimensions and the time direction points to the 2D nearest neighbors.

Directed percolation with multiple neighbors

Directed Percolation neighborhoods for extended range. Upper: z = 2, 4, 6; lower: z = 3, 5

(1+1)-d square with z NN, square lattice for z odd, tilted square lattice for z even

Lattice z Site percolation threshold Bond percolation threshold
(1+1)-d square 3 0.4395(3),[276]
(1+1)-d square 5 0.2249(3)[276]
(1+1)-d square 7 0.1470(2)[276]
(1+1)-d square 9 0.1081(2)[276]
(1+1)-d square 11 0.0851(2)[276]
(1+1)-d square 13 0.0701(2)[276]
(1+1)-d tilted sq 2 0.6447(2)[276]
(1+1)-d tilted sq 4 0.3272(2)[276]
(1+1)-d tilted sq 6 0.2121(3)[276]
(1+1)-d tilted sq 8 0.1553(3)[276]
(1+1)-d tilted sq 10 0.1220(2)[276]
(1+1)-d tilted sq 12 0.0999(2)[276]

For large z, pc ~ 1/z [277]

Site-Bond Directed Percolation

p_b = bond threshold

p_s = site threshold

Site-bond percolation is equivalent to having different probabilities of connections:

P_0 = probability that no sites are connected

P_2 = probability that exactly one descendant is connected to the upper vertex (two connected together)

P_3 = probability that both descendants are connected to the original vertex (all three connected together)

Formulas:

P_0 = (1-p_s) + p_s(1-p_b)^2

P_2 = p_s p_b (1-p_b)

P_3 = p_s p_b^2

P_0 + 2P_2 + P_3 = 1

Lattice z p_s p_b P_0 P_2 P_3
(1+1)-d square [278] 3 0.644701 1 0.126237 0.229062 0.415639
0.7 0.93585 0.148376 0.196529 0.458567
0.75 0.88565 0.169703 0.166059 0.498178
0.8 0.84135 0.192304 0.134616 0.538464
0.85 0.80190 0.216143 0.102242 0.579373
0.9 0.76645 0.241215 0.068981 0.620825
0.95 0.73450 0.267336 0.034889 0.662886
1 0.705489 0.294511 0 0.705489

Exact critical manifolds of inhomogeneous systems

Inhomogeneous triangular lattice bond percolation[20]

1p1p2p3+p1p2p3=0

Inhomogeneous honeycomb lattice bond percolation = kagome lattice site percolation[20]

1p1p2p1p3p2p3+p1p2p3=0

Inhomogeneous (3,12^2) lattice, site percolation[7][279]

13(s1s2)2+(s1s2)3=0, or s1s2=12sin(π/18)

Inhomogeneous union-jack lattice, site percolation with probabilities p1,p2,p3,p4[280]

p3=1p1;p4=1p2

Inhomogeneous martini lattice, bond percolation[73][281]

1(p1p2r3+p2p3r1+p1p3r2)(p1p2r1r2+p1p3r1r3+p2p3r2r3)+p1p2p3(r1r2+r1r3+r2r3)+r1r2r3(p1p2+p1p3+p2p3)2p1p2p3r1r2r3=0

Inhomogeneous martini lattice, site percolation. r = site in the star

1r(p1p2+p1p3+p2p3p1p2p3)=0

Inhomogeneous martini-A (3–7) lattice, bond percolation. Left side (top of "A" to bottom): r2, p1. Right side: r1, p2. Cross bond:  r3.

1p1r2p2r1p1p2r3p1r1r3p2r2r3+p1p2r1r3+p1p2r2r3+p1r1r2r3+p2r1r2r3p1p2r1r2r3=0

Inhomogeneous martini-B (3–5) lattice, bond percolation

Inhomogeneous martini lattice with outside enclosing triangle of bonds, probabilities y,x,z from inside to outside, bond percolation[281]

13z+z3(1z2)[3x2y(1+yy2)(1+z)+x3y2(32y)(1+2z)]=0

Inhomogeneous checkerboard lattice, bond percolation[57][91]

1(p1p2+p1p3+p1p4+p2p3+p2p4+p3p4)+p1p2p3+p1p2p4+p1p3p4+p2p3p4=0

Inhomogeneous bow-tie lattice, bond percolation[56][91]

1(p1p2+p1p3+p1p4+p2p3+p2p4+p3p4)+p1p2p3+p1p2p4+p1p3p4+p2p3p4u(1p1p2p3p4+p1p2p3p4)=0

where p1,p2,p3,p4 are the four bonds around the square and u is the diagonal bond connecting the vertex between bonds p4,p1 and p2,p3.

See also

Template:Div col

Template:Div col end

References

Template:Reflist

  1. Template:Cite book
  2. Template:Cite journal
  3. 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 Template:Cite book
  4. Template:Cite journal
  5. Template:Cite journal
  6. 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 Template:Cite book
  7. 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named SudingZiff99
  8. 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Parviainen07
  9. 9.0 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 9.8 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DingFuGuoWu10
  10. 10.0 10.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named ScullardJacobsen12
  11. 11.00 11.01 11.02 11.03 11.04 11.05 11.06 11.07 11.08 11.09 11.10 11.11 11.12 11.13 11.14 11.15 11.16 11.17 11.18 11.19 11.20 11.21 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Jacobsen14
  12. 12.0 12.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named JacobsenScullard13
  13. 13.0 13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 13.6 13.7 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named ScullardJacobsen19
  14. 14.0 14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named dIribarneRasigniRasigni95
  15. 15.00 15.01 15.02 15.03 15.04 15.05 15.06 15.07 15.08 15.09 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named dIribarneRasigniRasigni99b
  16. 16.0 16.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named SchlieckerKaiser99
  17. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DjordjevicStanleyMargolina82
  18. 18.0 18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named FengDengBlote08
  19. 19.0 19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4 19.5 19.6 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named ZiffGu08
  20. 20.0 20.1 20.2 20.3 20.4 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named SykesEssam
  21. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named ZiffSuding97
  22. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Scullard12
  23. 23.0 23.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Jacobsen15
  24. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named LinMa83
  25. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DerridaStauffer85
  26. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Yang13
  27. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named NewmanZiff
  28. Template:Cite journal
  29. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named deOliveiraNobregaStauffer03
  30. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Lee07
  31. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Lee08
  32. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named LevenshteinEtAl75
  33. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DeanBird67
  34. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Dean63
  35. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Tencer2021
  36. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Betts95
  37. 37.0 37.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named dIribarneRasigniRasigni99c
  38. 38.00 38.01 38.02 38.03 38.04 38.05 38.06 38.07 38.08 38.09 38.10 38.11 38.12 38.13 38.14 38.15 38.16 38.17 38.18 38.19 38.20 38.21 38.22 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named vanderMarck97a
  39. 39.0 39.1 39.2 39.3 39.4 39.5 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named MalarzGalam05
  40. 40.00 40.01 40.02 40.03 40.04 40.05 40.06 40.07 40.08 40.09 40.10 40.11 40.12 40.13 40.14 40.15 40.16 40.17 40.18 40.19 40.20 40.21 40.22 40.23 40.24 40.25 40.26 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Majewski2007
  41. 41.00 41.01 41.02 41.03 41.04 41.05 41.06 41.07 41.08 41.09 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DaltonDombSykes64
  42. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Collier
  43. 43.00 43.01 43.02 43.03 43.04 43.05 43.06 43.07 43.08 43.09 43.10 43.11 43.12 43.13 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named OuyangDengBlote18
  44. 44.0 44.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named XuWangHaoDeng20
  45. 45.00 45.01 45.02 45.03 45.04 45.05 45.06 45.07 45.08 45.09 45.10 45.11 45.12 45.13 45.14 45.15 45.16 45.17 45.18 45.19 45.20 45.21 45.22 45.23 45.24 45.25 Template:Cite journal
  46. 46.0 46.1 46.2 46.3 46.4 46.5 46.6 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Malarz21
  47. 47.0 47.1 47.2 47.3 47.4 47.5 47.6 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Malarz20
  48. 48.0 48.1 48.2 48.3 48.4 48.5 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DombDalton66
  49. 49.0 49.1 49.2 49.3 49.4 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named GoukerFamily83
  50. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Malarz22
  51. 51.00 51.01 51.02 51.03 51.04 51.05 51.06 51.07 51.08 51.09 51.10 51.11 51.12 51.13 51.14 51.15 51.16 51.17 51.18 51.19 51.20 51.21 51.22 51.23 51.24 51.25 51.26 51.27 51.28 51.29 51.30 51.31 51.32 51.33 51.34 51.35 51.36 51.37 51.38 51.39 51.40 51.41 51.42 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named MeckeSeyfried02
  52. 52.00 52.01 52.02 52.03 52.04 52.05 52.06 52.07 52.08 52.09 52.10 52.11 52.12 52.13 52.14 52.15 52.16 52.17 52.18 52.19 52.20 52.21 52.22 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named KozaKondratSuszcaynski14
  53. 53.0 53.1 53.2 53.3 53.4 53.5 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DengOuyangBlote19
  54. 54.0 54.1 54.2 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named MitraSahaSensharma19
  55. 55.0 55.1 55.2 55.3 55.4 55.5 Template:Cite journal
  56. 56.0 56.1 56.2 56.3 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named ScullardZiff10
  57. 57.0 57.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Wu79
  58. 58.0 58.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named MaiHalley80
  59. 59.00 59.01 59.02 59.03 59.04 59.05 59.06 59.07 59.08 59.09 Template:Cite journal
  60. Template:Cite journal
  61. Template:Cite journal
  62. Template:Cite journal
  63. 63.0 63.1 63.2 63.3 63.4 63.5 63.6 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named HoviAharony96
  64. 64.00 64.01 64.02 64.03 64.04 64.05 64.06 64.07 64.08 64.09 64.10 64.11 64.12 64.13 64.14 64.15 64.16 64.17 64.18 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named TarasevichVanDerMarck99
  65. 65.00 65.01 65.02 65.03 65.04 65.05 65.06 65.07 65.08 65.09 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named GonzálezFloresTorresLebrechtRamirezPastor21
  66. 66.0 66.1 66.2 66.3 66.4 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named SakamotoYonezawaHori89
  67. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DengEtAl11
  68. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Syozi82
  69. 69.00 69.01 69.02 69.03 69.04 69.05 69.06 69.07 69.08 69.09 69.10 69.11 69.12 69.13 69.14 69.15 69.16 69.17 69.18 69.19 69.20 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named NeherEtAl08
  70. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named GrimmettManolescu12
  71. 71.0 71.1 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Scullard06
  72. 72.0 72.1 72.2 72.3 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Ziff06
  73. 73.00 73.01 73.02 73.03 73.04 73.05 73.06 73.07 73.08 73.09 73.10 73.11 73.12 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named ScullardZiff06
  74. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DingWangLi12
  75. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Wierman84
  76. 76.00 76.01 76.02 76.03 76.04 76.05 76.06 76.07 76.08 76.09 76.10 76.11 76.12 76.13 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named MelchertKatzgraberNovotny15
  77. Template:Cite journal
  78. 78.00 78.01 78.02 78.03 78.04 78.05 78.06 78.07 78.08 78.09 78.10 Template:Cite journal
  79. 79.0 79.1 Template:Cite journal
  80. 80.0 80.1 80.2 Template:Cite journal
  81. 81.0 81.1 81.2 81.3 81.4 81.5 81.6 81.7 81.8 Template:Cite journal
  82. 82.0 82.1 82.2 82.3 Template:Cite journal
  83. 83.0 83.1 Template:Cite journal
  84. 84.0 84.1 84.2 84.3 Template:Cite journal
  85. 85.0 85.1 85.2 85.3 85.4 85.5 85.6 Template:Cite journal
  86. Template:Cite journal
  87. 87.0 87.1 87.2 87.3 87.4 87.5 87.6 Template:Cite journal
  88. Template:Cite journal
  89. 89.0 89.1 89.2 89.3 Template:Cite journal
  90. 90.00 90.01 90.02 90.03 90.04 90.05 90.06 90.07 90.08 90.09 90.10 90.11 90.12 90.13 90.14 90.15 90.16 90.17 90.18 90.19 90.20 90.21 90.22 90.23 90.24 90.25 90.26 90.27 90.28 90.29 Template:Cite journal
  91. 91.0 91.1 91.2 Template:Cite journal
  92. 92.00 92.01 92.02 92.03 92.04 92.05 92.06 92.07 92.08 92.09 92.10 Template:Cite journal
  93. 93.0 93.1 93.2 93.3 Template:Cite journal
  94. 94.0 94.1 94.2 Template:Cite journal
  95. Template:Cite journal
  96. Template:Cite journal
  97. 97.0 97.1 Template:Cite journal
  98. 98.00 98.01 98.02 98.03 98.04 98.05 98.06 98.07 98.08 98.09 98.10 98.11 98.12 98.13 98.14 98.15 98.16 98.17 Template:Cite journal
  99. 99.0 99.1 99.2 Template:Cite journal
  100. 100.00 100.01 100.02 100.03 100.04 100.05 100.06 100.07 100.08 100.09 100.10 Template:Cite journal
  101. Template:Cite journal
  102. Template:Cite journal
  103. 103.0 103.1 103.2 103.3 103.4 103.5 103.6 103.7 Template:Cite journal
  104. Template:Cite journal
  105. Template:Cite journal
  106. 106.0 106.1 106.2 Template:Cite journal
  107. 107.00 107.01 107.02 107.03 107.04 107.05 107.06 107.07 107.08 107.09 107.10 107.11 107.12 107.13 107.14 107.15 107.16 107.17 107.18 Template:Cite journal
  108. Template:Cite journal
  109. Template:Cite journal
  110. 110.00 110.01 110.02 110.03 110.04 110.05 110.06 110.07 110.08 110.09 110.10 110.11 110.12 110.13 110.14 110.15 110.16 110.17 110.18 110.19 110.20 Template:Cite journal
  111. 111.00 111.01 111.02 111.03 111.04 111.05 111.06 111.07 111.08 111.09 111.10 111.11 111.12 111.13 111.14 111.15 111.16 111.17 111.18 111.19 111.20 111.21 111.22 111.23 111.24 111.25 Template:Cite journal
  112. 112.00 112.01 112.02 112.03 112.04 112.05 112.06 112.07 112.08 112.09 112.10 112.11 Template:Cite journal
  113. 113.00 113.01 113.02 113.03 113.04 113.05 113.06 113.07 113.08 113.09 113.10 113.11 113.12 113.13 113.14 Template:Cite journal
  114. Template:Cite journal
  115. 115.0 115.1 115.2 Template:Cite journal
  116. 116.0 116.1 116.2 116.3 116.4 116.5 116.6 116.7 116.8 Template:Cite journal
  117. 117.0 117.1 Template:Cite journal
  118. 118.0 118.1 118.2 118.3 118.4 118.5 118.6 Template:Cite journal
  119. 119.0 119.1 Template:Cite journal
  120. Template:Cite journal
  121. Template:Cite journal
  122. 122.0 122.1 122.2 Template:Cite journal
  123. 123.0 123.1 Template:Cite journal
  124. 124.0 124.1 124.2 124.3 124.4 Template:Cite journal
  125. Template:Cite journal
  126. 126.0 126.1 126.2 Template:Cite journal
  127. 127.0 127.1 Template:Cite journal
  128. 128.0 128.1 Template:Cite journal
  129. 129.0 129.1 Template:Cite journal
  130. Template:Cite journal
  131. Template:Cite journal
  132. Template:Cite journal
  133. Template:Cite journal
  134. 134.0 134.1 134.2 134.3 134.4 134.5 134.6 134.7 Template:Cite journal
  135. Template:Cite journal
  136. Template:Cite journal
  137. Template:Cite journal
  138. 138.0 138.1 138.2 Template:Cite journal
  139. 139.0 139.1 139.2 139.3 139.4 139.5 139.6 Template:Cite journal
  140. 140.00 140.01 140.02 140.03 140.04 140.05 140.06 140.07 140.08 140.09 140.10 140.11 140.12 140.13 140.14 140.15 140.16 140.17 140.18 140.19 140.20 140.21 140.22 140.23 140.24 140.25 140.26 140.27 Template:Cite journal
  141. 141.0 141.1 141.2 141.3 141.4 141.5 141.6 Template:Cite journal
  142. 142.0 142.1 142.2 142.3 142.4 142.5 142.6 142.7 Template:Cite journal
  143. 143.00 143.01 143.02 143.03 143.04 143.05 143.06 143.07 143.08 143.09 143.10 Template:Cite journal
  144. Template:Cite journal
  145. 145.0 145.1 Template:Cite journal
  146. Template:Cite journal
  147. 147.00 147.01 147.02 147.03 147.04 147.05 147.06 147.07 147.08 147.09 Template:Cite journal
  148. 148.0 148.1 Template:Cite journal
  149. 149.0 149.1 Template:Cite journal
  150. 150.0 150.1 150.2 150.3 150.4 150.5 150.6 Template:Cite journal
  151. 151.0 151.1 151.2 151.3 Template:Cite journal
  152. Template:Cite journal
  153. 153.0 153.1 Template:Cite journal
  154. 154.00 154.01 154.02 154.03 154.04 154.05 154.06 154.07 154.08 154.09 154.10 154.11 154.12 154.13 154.14 154.15 154.16 154.17 154.18 154.19 Template:Cite journal
  155. 155.0 155.1 Template:Cite journal
  156. 156.0 156.1 156.2 156.3 156.4 156.5 156.6 156.7 Template:Cite journal
  157. 157.0 157.1 157.2 157.3 157.4 157.5 Template:Cite journal
  158. Template:Cite journal
  159. 159.0 159.1 Template:Cite journal
  160. Template:Cite journal
  161. Template:Cite journal
  162. Template:Cite journal
  163. Template:Cite journal
  164. Template:Cite journal
  165. 165.0 165.1 165.2 Template:Cite journal
  166. 166.00 166.01 166.02 166.03 166.04 166.05 166.06 166.07 166.08 166.09 166.10 Template:Cite journal
  167. Template:Cite journal
  168. 168.0 168.1 168.2 168.3 Template:Cite journal
  169. 169.0 169.1 169.2 169.3 169.4 169.5 169.6 169.7 Template:Cite journal
  170. 170.0 170.1 170.2 Template:Cite journal
  171. 171.0 171.1 Template:Cite journal
  172. Template:Cite journal
  173. Template:Cite journal
  174. 174.0 174.1 174.2 174.3 174.4 174.5 Template:Cite journal
  175. Template:Cite journal
  176. Template:Cite journal
  177. 177.00 177.01 177.02 177.03 177.04 177.05 177.06 177.07 177.08 177.09 177.10 177.11 177.12 177.13 177.14 177.15 177.16 177.17 177.18 177.19 177.20 177.21 177.22 177.23 177.24 177.25 177.26 177.27 177.28 177.29 177.30 177.31 177.32 177.33 Template:Cite journal
  178. 178.0 178.1 Template:Cite journal
  179. Template:Cite journal
  180. 180.0 180.1 180.2 180.3 180.4 180.5 180.6 Template:Cite journal
  181. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named XunHaoZiff21
  182. 182.00 182.01 182.02 182.03 182.04 182.05 182.06 182.07 182.08 182.09 Template:Cite journal
  183. 183.0 183.1 183.2 183.3 Template:Cite journal
  184. Template:Cite journal
  185. 185.0 185.1 185.2 Template:Cite journal
  186. Template:Cite journal
  187. Template:Cite journal
  188. Template:Cite journal
  189. 189.0 189.1 189.2 189.3 189.4 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named MitraSahaSensharma22
  190. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named TarasevichCherkasova07
  191. Template:Cite journal
  192. Template:Cite journal
  193. Template:Cite journal
  194. 194.0 194.1 Template:Cite journal
  195. Template:Cite journal
  196. 196.0 196.1 196.2 196.3 196.4 196.5 196.6 196.7 Template:Cite journal
  197. 197.0 197.1 Template:Cite journal
  198. 198.0 198.1 198.2 198.3 198.4 198.5 198.6 198.7 198.8 Template:Cite journal
  199. 199.00 199.01 199.02 199.03 199.04 199.05 199.06 199.07 199.08 199.09 199.10 199.11 199.12 199.13 199.14 199.15 199.16 199.17 199.18 199.19 199.20 199.21 199.22 199.23 199.24 199.25 199.26 199.27 199.28 199.29 199.30 199.31 199.32 199.33 199.34 Template:Cite journal
  200. 200.0 200.1 200.2 200.3 Template:Cite journal
  201. Template:Cite journal
  202. 202.0 202.1 202.2 202.3 202.4 202.5 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named DallChristensen02
  203. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named GoriTrombettoni15
  204. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named BalbergBinenbaum82
  205. 205.00 205.01 205.02 205.03 205.04 205.05 205.06 205.07 205.08 205.09 Template:Cite journal
  206. 206.0 206.1 206.2 Template:Cite journal
  207. 207.0 207.1 207.2 207.3 207.4 Template:Cite journal
  208. 208.0 208.1 208.2 Template:Cite journal
  209. 209.0 209.1 209.2 Template:Cite journal
  210. 210.0 210.1 Template:Cite journal
  211. 211.0 211.1 211.2 211.3 211.4 211.5 Template:Cite journal
  212. Template:Cite journal
  213. Template:Cite journal
  214. 214.00 214.01 214.02 214.03 214.04 214.05 214.06 214.07 214.08 214.09 214.10 214.11 Template:Cite journal
  215. 215.0 215.1 215.2 215.3 215.4 215.5 215.6 215.7 215.8 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named NovakGaoKraikivskiSlepchenko11
  216. 216.0 216.1 216.2 216.3 216.4 216.5 Template:Cite journal
  217. 217.00 217.01 217.02 217.03 217.04 217.05 217.06 217.07 217.08 217.09 217.10 217.11 217.12 217.13 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named BallowLintonPriour22
  218. 218.0 218.1 Template:Cite arXiv
  219. Template:Cite journal
  220. Template:Cite journal
  221. Template:Cite journal
  222. 222.0 222.1 Template:Cite journal
  223. Template:Cite journal
  224. Template:Cite journal
  225. Template:Cite journal
  226. 226.0 226.1 226.2 226.3 226.4 226.5 Template:Cite journal
  227. Template:Cite journal
  228. Template:Cite journal
  229. Template:Cite journal
  230. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named GrassbergerHilarioSidoravicius17
  231. 231.0 231.1 Template:Cite journal
  232. Template:Cite journal
  233. 233.0 233.1 233.2 Template:Cite journal
  234. 234.0 234.1 234.2 234.3 Template:Cite journal
  235. 235.00 235.01 235.02 235.03 235.04 235.05 235.06 235.07 235.08 235.09 235.10 235.11 235.12 235.13 235.14 235.15 235.16 235.17 235.18 235.19 Template:Cite journal
  236. 236.0 236.1 Template:Cite journal
  237. Template:Cite journal
  238. 238.0 238.1 238.2 238.3 238.4 238.5 238.6 Template:Cite journal
  239. 239.00 239.01 239.02 239.03 239.04 239.05 239.06 239.07 239.08 239.09 239.10 239.11 239.12 239.13 239.14 239.15 239.16 239.17 239.18 239.19 Template:Cite journal
  240. 240.0 240.1 240.2 240.3 Template:Cite journal
  241. 241.0 241.1 241.2 241.3 Template:Cite journal
  242. 242.0 242.1 Template:Cite journal
  243. 243.0 243.1 243.2 243.3 243.4 Template:Cite journal
  244. Template:Cite journal
  245. Template:Cite journal
  246. 246.00 246.01 246.02 246.03 246.04 246.05 246.06 246.07 246.08 246.09 246.10 246.11 246.12 246.13 246.14 246.15 246.16 246.17 Template:Cite journal
  247. 247.0 247.1 Template:Cite journal
  248. 248.0 248.1 Template:Cite journal
  249. Template:Cite journal
  250. 250.0 250.1 Template:Cite journal
  251. Template:Cite journal
  252. 252.0 252.1 252.2 Template:Cite journal
  253. 253.00 253.01 253.02 253.03 253.04 253.05 253.06 253.07 253.08 253.09 253.10 253.11 253.12 253.13 253.14 253.15 253.16 253.17 253.18 253.19 253.20 253.21 253.22 253.23 253.24 253.25 253.26 253.27 253.28 253.29 253.30 253.31 253.32 253.33 253.34 253.35 253.36 253.37 253.38 253.39 Template:Cite journal
  254. 254.0 254.1 254.2 Template:Cite journal
  255. 255.0 255.1 255.2 255.3 255.4 255.5 255.6 255.7 255.8 Template:Cite journal
  256. 256.0 256.1 256.2 256.3 256.4 256.5 256.6 256.7 Template:Cite journal
  257. 257.0 257.1 257.2 257.3 Template:Cite journal
  258. 258.0 258.1 Template:Cite journal
  259. Template:Cite journal
  260. 260.00 260.01 260.02 260.03 260.04 260.05 260.06 260.07 260.08 260.09 260.10 260.11 260.12 260.13 260.14 260.15 260.16 260.17 260.18 260.19 260.20 260.21 260.22 260.23 260.24 260.25 260.26 260.27 260.28 260.29 260.30 260.31 260.32 260.33 Template:Cite journal
  261. 261.0 261.1 Template:Cite journal
  262. 262.0 262.1 Template:Cite journal
  263. 263.0 263.1 263.2 263.3 Template:Cite journal
  264. Template:Cite journal
  265. 265.0 265.1 Template:Cite journal
  266. Template:Cite journal
  267. Template:Cite journal
  268. 268.0 268.1 268.2 Template:Cite journal
  269. 269.00 269.01 269.02 269.03 269.04 269.05 269.06 269.07 269.08 269.09 Template:Cite journal
  270. 270.0 270.1 270.2 Template:Cite journal
  271. 271.0 271.1 271.2 271.3 271.4 271.5 Template:Cite journal
  272. 272.0 272.1 272.2 272.3 Template:Cite journal
  273. Template:Cite journal
  274. Template:Cite journal
  275. 275.0 275.1 Template:Cite journal
  276. 276.00 276.01 276.02 276.03 276.04 276.05 276.06 276.07 276.08 276.09 276.10 276.11 Template:Cite journal
  277. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Soar SoaresEtAl06 es
  278. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named TretyakovInui95
  279. Template:Cite journal
  280. Template:Cite journal
  281. 281.0 281.1 Template:Cite journal