Minimum railway curve radius

Template:Convert radii on the elevated Template:Track gauge Chicago 'L'. There is no room for longer radii at this cross junction in the northwest corner of the Loop.

The minimum railway curve radius is the shortest allowable design radius for the centerline of railway tracks under a particular set of conditions. It has an important bearing on construction costs and operating costs and, in combination with superelevation (difference in elevation of the two rails) in the case of train tracks, determines the maximum safe speed of a curve. The minimum radius of a curve is one parameter in the design of railway vehicles as well as trams; monorails and automated guideways are also subject to a minimum radius.

History

The first proper railway was the Liverpool and Manchester Railway, which opened in 1830. Like the tram roads that had preceded it over a hundred years, the L&M had gentle curves and gradients. Reasons for these gentle curves include the lack of strength of the track, which might have overturned if the curves were too sharp causing derailments. The gentler the curves, the greater the visibility, thus boosting safety via increased situational awareness. The earliest rails were made in short lengths of wrought iron,Template:Cn which does not bend like later steel rails introduced in the 1850s.

Factors affecting the minimum curve radius

Minimum curve radii for railways are governed by the speed operated and by the mechanical ability of the rolling stock to adjust to the curvature. In North America, equipment for unlimited interchange between railway companies is built to accommodate for a Template:Convert radius, but normally a Template:Convert radius is used as a minimum, as some freight carriages (freight cars) are handled by special agreement between railways that cannot take the sharper curvature. For the handling of long freight trains, a minimum Template:Convert radius is preferred.

The sharpest curves tend to be on the narrowest of narrow gauge railways, where almost all the equipment is proportionately smaller. But standard gauge can also have tight curves, if rolling stocks are built for it, which however removes the standardisation benefit of standard gauge. Tramways can have below Template:Convert curve radius.

Steam locomotives

As the need for more powerful steam locomotives grew, the need for more driving wheels on a longer, fixed wheelbase grew too. But long wheel bases do not cope well with curves of a small radius. Various types of articulated locomotives (e.g., Mallet, Garratt, Meyer & Fairlie) were devised to avoid having to operate multiple locomotives with multiple crews.

More recent diesel and electric locomotives do not have a wheelbase problem, as they have flexible bogies, and also can easily be operated in multiple with a single crew.

• The Tasmanian Government Railways K class was
  • Template:RailGauge gauge
  • Template:Convert radius curves
• Example Garratt
  • Template:RailGauge
  • Template:Convert rails
  • Main line radius - Template:Convert
  • Siding radius - Template:Convert
• 0-4-0
  • GER Class 209
  • Template:RailGauge

Couplings

Not all couplers can handle very short radii. This is particularly true of the European buffer and chain couplers, where the buffers extend the length of the rail car body. For a line with a maximum speed of Template:Convert, buffer-and-chain couplers increase the minimum radius to around Template:Convert. As narrow-gauge railways, tramways, and rapid transit systems normally do not interchange with mainline railways, instances of these types of railway in Europe often use bufferless central couplers and build to a tighter standard.

Train lengths

A long heavy freight train, especially those with wagons of mixed loading, may struggle on short radius curves, as the drawgear forces may pull intermediate wagons off the rails. Common solutions include:

• marshaling light and empty wagons at the rear of the train
• intermediate locomotives, including remotely controlled ones
• easing curves
• reduced speeds
• reduced cant (superelevation), at the expense of fast passenger trains
• more, shorter trains
• equalizing wagon loading (often employed on unit trains)
• better driver training
• driving controls that display drawgear forces
• Electronically Controlled Pneumatic brakes

A similar problem occurs with harsh changes in gradients (vertical curves).

Speed and cant

As a heavy train goes around a bend at speed, the reactive centrifugal force may cause negative effects: passengers and cargo may experience unpleasant forces, the inside and outside rails will wear unequally, and insufficiently anchored tracks may move.Template:Dubious To counter this, a cant (superelevation) is used. Ideally, the train should be tilted such that resultant force acts vertically downwards through the bottom of the train, so the wheels, track, train and passengers feel little or no sideways force ("down" and "sideways" are given with respect to the plane of the track and train). Some trains are capable of tilting to enhance this effect for passenger comfort. Because freight and passenger trains tend to move at different speeds, a cant cannot be ideal for both types of rail traffic.

The relationship between speed and tilt can be calculated mathematically. We start with the formula for a balancing centripetal force: θ is the angle by which the train is tilted due to the cant, r is the curve radius in meters, v is the speed in meters per second, and g is the standard gravity, approximately equal to 9.81 m/s²:

$\tan \theta =\frac{v^2}{gr}$

Rearranging for r gives:

$r=\frac{v^2}{g\tan \theta }$

Geometrically, tan θ can be expressed (using the small-angle approximation) in terms of the track gauge G, the cant h_a and cant deficiency h_b, all in millimeters:

$\tan \theta \approx \sin \theta =\frac{h_a+h_b}{G}$

This approximation for tan θ gives:

$r=\frac{v^2}{g\frac{h_a+h_b}{G}}=\frac{G{v}^2}{g(h_a+h_b)}$

This table shows examples of curve radii. The values used when building high-speed railways vary, and depend on desired wear and safety levels.

Curve radius	Template:Cvt	Template:Cvt	Template:Cvt	Template:Cvt	Template:Cvt	Template:Cvt
Cant Template:Convert, cant deficiency Template:Convert, no tilting trains	Template:Convert	Template:Convert	Template:Convert	Template:Convert	Template:Convert	Template:Convert
Cant Template:Convert, cant deficiency Template:Convert, with tilting trains	Template:Convert	Template:Convert	Template:Convert	no tilting trains planned for these speedsTemplate:Why

Tramways typically do not exhibit cant, due to the low speeds involved. Instead, they use the outer grooves of rails as a guide in tight curves.

Transition curves

A curve should not become a straight all at once, but should gradually increase in radius over time (a distance of around Template:Cvt for a line with a maximum speed of about Template:Cvt). Even sharper than curves with no transition are reverse curves with no intervening straight track. The superelevation must also be transitioned. Higher speeds require longer transitions.

Vertical curves

As a train negotiates a curve, the force it exerts on the track changes. Too tight a 'crest' curve could result in the train leaving the track as it drops away beneath it; too tight a 'trough' and the train will plough downwards into the rails and damage them. More precisely, the support force R exerted by the track on a train as a function of the curve radius r, the train mass Template:Mvar, and the speed Template:Mvar, is given by

$R=mg\pm \frac{m{v}^2}{r}$

with the second term positive for troughs, negative for crests. For passenger comfort the ratio of the gravitational acceleration g to the centripetal acceleration v²/r needs to be kept as small as possible, else passengers will feel large changes in their weight.

As trains cannot climb steep slopes, they have little occasion to go over significant vertical curves. However, high-speed trains are sufficiently high-powered that steep slopes are preferable to the reduced speed necessary to navigate horizontal curves around obstacles, or the higher construction costs necessary to tunnel through or bridge over them. High Speed 1 (section 2) in the UK has a minimum vertical curve radius of Template:Convert and High Speed 2, with the higher speed of Template:Convert, stipulates much larger Template:Convert radii. In both these cases the experienced change in weight is less than 7%.

Rail well cars also risk low clearance at the tops of tight crests.

Problem curves

• The Australian Standard Garratt had flangeless leading driving wheels that tended to cause derailments on sharp curves.
• Sharp curves on the Port Augusta to Hawker line of the South Australian Railways caused derailment problems when bigger and heavier X class locomotives were introduced, requiring realignments to ease the curves.
• Template:Convert curves on the Oberon, Batlow, and Dorrigo lines, New South Wales limited steam locomotives to the 0-6-0 19 class.

List of selected minimum curve radii

Radius	Location	Gauge	Notes
Template:Convert	Japan	N/A (maglev)	Chūō Shinkansen (Template:Cvt)
Template:Convert	Chinese high speed railway network	Template:Track gauge	Template:Cvt
Template:Convert		Template:Track gauge	Template:Cvt
Template:Convert		Template:Track gauge	Template:Cvt
Template:Convert		Template:Track gauge	Template:Cvt
Template:Convert		Template:Track gauge	Template:Cvt
Template:Convert	Africa	Template:Track gauge	Typical of medium-speed railways (Template:Cvt) Passenger
		Template:Track gauge	Typical of medium-speed railways (Template:Cvt) Freight
Template:Convert		Template:Track gauge	Typical of medium-speed railways (Template:Cvt) Passenger
Template:Convert		Template:Track gauge	Typical of medium-speed railways (Template:Cvt) Freight
Template:Convert	DRCongo Matadi–Kinshasa Railway	Template:Track gauge	Deviated Template:Track gauge line.
Template:Convert	Border Loop	Template:Track gauge	Template:Convert - Template:Convert
Template:Convert	Wollstonecraft station, Sydney	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Homebush triangle	Template:Track gauge	Template:Convert - Template:Convert
Template:Convert	Turkey	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Indian Railways	Template:Track gauge
	North American rail network	Template:Track gauge	Preferred minimum on freight main lines
Template:Convert	Lithgow Zig Zag	Template:Track gauge	40 km/h
Template:Convert	North American rail network	Template:Track gauge	Minimum radius for general service
Template:Convert	Bay Area Rapid Transit	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Batlow, New South Wales	Template:Track gauge	Rolling stock limited to Template:Convert and Template:Convert - restricted to NSW Z19 class 0-6-0 steam locomotives
Template:Convert	Newmarket, New Zealand	Template:Track gauge	Extra heavy concrete sleepers
Template:Convert	North American rail network	Template:Track gauge	Absolute minimum radius; not on lines for general service
Template:Convert	Windberg Railway (de:Windbergbahn)	Template:Track gauge	(between Freital-Birkigt and Dresden-Gittersee) - restrictions to wheelbase
Template:Convert	Queensland Railways	Template:Track gauge	Central Line between Bogantungan and Hannam's Gap
Template:Convert	JFK Airtrain	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Washington Metro	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	London Underground Central line	Template:Track gauge	(between White City and Shepherd's Bush)
Template:Convert	New York City Subway	Template:Track gauge	Several 175-foot curves of the BMT Eastern Division do not permit the 75-foot cars through them
Template:Convert	Gotham Curve	Template:Track gauge	Cromford and High Peak Railway, Derbyshire, England until 1967
	Matadi-Kinshasa Railway	Template:Track gauge	original Template:Track gauge line.
	Welsh Highland Railway	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Bernina Railway	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Welsh Highland Railway	Template:Track gauge	on original line at Beddgelert
	Victorian Narrow Gauge	Template:Track gauge	Template:Convert on curves (Template:Convert on straightaways)
Template:Convert (48°)	Kalka-Shimla Railway	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Metromover	N/A (monorail)	Rubber-tired, monorail-guided light rail downtown people mover system.
Template:Convert	New York City Subway	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Chicago 'L'	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Sydney Steam Motor Tram 0-4-0	Template:Track gauge	Hauling 3 trailers
	Luas
Template:Convert	Warsaw Commuter Railway	Template:Track gauge	Depot tracks in Grodzisk Mazowiecki, Poland
Template:Convert	Darjeeling Himalayan Railway	Template:Track gauge	Sharpest curves were originally Template:Convert
Template:Convert	Matheran Hill Railway	Template:Track gauge	1 in 20 (5%); Template:Convert on curve; Template:Convert on straight
Template:Convert	Streetcars in New Orleans	Template:Track gauge	Revenue service
Template:Convert		Template:Track gauge	Yard tracks
Template:Convert	San Francisco Municipal Railway	Template:Track gauge	Light rail, former streetcar system
Template:Convert	Toronto Streetcar System	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Taunton Tramway	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Boston Green Line	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Newark Light Rail	Template:Track gauge
Template:Convert	Chicago Tunnel Company	Template:Track gauge	Template:Convert in grand unions. Not in use.

See also

• Breakover angle
• Category:Articulated locomotives
• Degree of curvature, civil engineering
• Lateral motion device
• Longest trains
• Matheran Hill Railway
• Radius
• Radius of curvature (applications)
• Railway systems engineering
• Track transition curve
• Turning radius

External links

• Template:Cite book